Sermon Transcript
From Ecclesiastes chapter 3. What gain has the worker from his toil? I have seen the business that God has given to the children of man to be busy with. He has made everything beautiful in its time. Also, he has put eternity into man’s heart, yet so that he cannot find out what God has done from the beginning to the end.
I perceived that there is nothing better for them than to be joyful and to do good as long as they live. Also, that everyone should eat and drink and take pleasure in all his toil. This is God’s gift to man. I perceived that whatever God does endures forever. Nothing can be added to it, nor anything taken from it.
God has done it so that the people fear before him. For what happens to the children of man and what happens to the beasts is the same. As one dies, so dies the other. They all have the same breath, and man has no advantage over the beasts, for all is vanity. All go to one place.
All are from the dust, and to dust all return. Who knows whether the spirit of man goes upward and the spirit of the beast goes down into the earth? So I saw that there is nothing better than that a man should rejoice in his work, for that is his lot. Who can bring him to see what will be after him?
Did you know, uh, in the first century, very little evangelism took place during a church service? Very little. Instead, the far majority of evangelism took place person to person, friend to friend, relative to relative. Evangelism didn’t happen at church because, for the most part, only Christians attended church, which is kind of like today, except back then there was a different reason that only Christians attended church. Back then, during the 1st century, Christians really didn’t want non-Christians showing up at church because very often in the 1st century, Christianity was persecuted either by religious establishment in Israel or political leadership in Rome.
And the Christians didn’t want to accidentally let in some type of official into their services who would blow the whistle on them and bring soldiers and persecute everyone who was there. So, for the most part, Christians would not invite people to church unless they were sure those people were already Christians. No one wanted to be the guy who accidentally tipped off the authorities and got everyone arrested. Nobody wanted to be that guy, so they didn’t invite people who weren’t Christians. So, they kept their meetings secret, but they didn’t keep their faith secret.
Faith secret. They shared their faith like crazy, person to person, friend to friend, relative to relative, and it was effective. Michael Green, in his landmark work Evangelism in the Early Church, he writes, the message of Jesus was not shared by formal preaching, but by the informal chattering to friends and chance acquaintances, in homes and wine shops, on walks and around market stalls. They went everywhere gossiping the gospel. They did it naturally, enthusiastically, and with the conviction of those not paid to say that sort of thing.
Consequently, they were taken seriously, and the movement spread notably among the lower classes. It spread, in fact, over the entire empire. And I believe we can do the same thing by the grace of God. I believe the message of Jesus can spread now as it did then.
But I also assume some of you are skeptical about that. Some of you have been burned so many times that it’s hard for you to believe that you could effectively share your faith faith now. So here’s what might be encouraging. Any reason that we think Christianity couldn’t spread now, the early church faced similar, if not more difficult circumstances. For instance, here’s some of our excuses.
We say, I can’t share my faith in Christ because our culture thinks Christianity is uneducated. It’s, it’s the religion for the ignorant, the unenlightened. First century, they thought the same thing. The Epicureans or the Stoics, the philosophers, they thought Christianity was foolish. They thought Christianity was unenlightened.
Or we say, I can’t share Christ because our culture thinks Christianity is closed-minded, narrow. First century, they thought the same thing. First century people actually called Christians atheists. Did you know that? Because Christians only believed in one God.
God. They were like, how can you be so exclusive, you close-minded fool? Same as today. Or we say, I can’t share faith in Christ because no one in our culture cares what the Bible says. I can’t say the Bible says this, nobody cares.
That’s true, they don’t care what the Bible says. But no one in the Roman Empire cared what the Jewish scriptures said, and the New Testament was still being written, so nobody cared what that Or we say, I can’t share Christ because people think Christianity is weird or offensive. Did you know in the 1st century many people thought Christians were cannibals?
Cannibals! Because Christians celebrated communion, right? They symbolically ate the body and blood of Jesus. But people outside of Christianity didn’t understand. They were just talking about wine and bread.
They didn’t know that. They thought Christians were literally eating flesh and blood. So if you told someone you were a Christian, right, and they thought you were a cannibal, right, they’re not really going to accept your dinner invite, right? Like, no thanks, I don’t want to be on the plate. I mean, you want to talk about being perceived as weird and offensive, cannibalism is about as extreme as you can get, right?
And yet Christians were successful articulating their faith individual to individual, person to person, friend to friend. They presented Christ in a way that people listened.
I think we can too, but I also think many of us are unprepared to do it, and I think we could use some help help knowing how to naturally, enthusiastically gossip our faith everywhere that we go. So that’s what we’re trying to do for 6 weeks. We’re in our 3rd week looking at 6 conversations that our friends, neighbors, colleagues often initiate, which we can enter into to show that Jesus is a better story. As a reminder, our 6 conversations are power— we’ve done that already— the vulnerable— we’ve done that already. Today is purpose, then we’ll have justice, friendship, and self-worth.
We really believe we can compellingly, thoughtfully, graciously show that Jesus is a better story in all of those conversations. That’s our primary goal with this series, okay? Show Jesus as the better story. Our second goal is to deepen or even begin our own faith. So this week, again, we’re looking at I’m gonna show you a video which isn’t going to make any sense, but I think you’ll enjoy it, and then we’ll keep referring back to it later.
So check out this video. Have you seen this before? There’s a bunch of these online.
That’s funny, isn’t it?
I know, you’re like, here he goes. You’re like, why did you show that, Dan? I don’t get it. Don’t worry, we’ll come back to it. As we look at our scripture for today, we’ll see the need for purpose, the futility of work, and finally, the purpose that God provides.
So the need for purpose, the futility of work, and then the purpose God provides. So first, the need for purpose is inescapable. The entire book of Ecclesiastes— I’d recommend reading the whole thing. I think it’ll take you about 30 minutes. But the author, this ancient author, strains to find meaning in life.
The author grapples with why are we here, why put forth effort, what really matters. For instance, at the beginning of our passage today, verse 9, he asked, what do we gain from all of our toil? He needs to know if all this is pointless, like, why am I doing it? And in these verses, he quasi comes to a solution. He’s like, I guess the best you can do is just enjoy what you do while it lasts.
But then elsewhere, like, he bemoans— elsewhere in the book of Ecclesiastes, he’s like, whether you enjoy it or not, everything you build ends up going to somebody else, and after you build it, it doesn’t actually bring you pleasure for very long. So what’s really the point? He, like, he strains to find meaning. Ecclesiastes brilliantly captures the human condition. It’s why it’s called wisdom literature.
It’s why it survived for thousands of years, because it speaks to who we are and what we need still, even today. Humans must have purpose. Purpose. We must work for something that actually matters. We ask, what do I gain from my toil?
And we must have an answer. Um, numerous studies show we live longer if we have purpose. Uh, 2019 study published by the Journal of the American Medical Association followed 7,000 adults over the age of 50. Massive study. The ones who reported the lowest sense of purpose in their life were twice as likely to die compared to those reporting the highest sense of purpose.
So back when that menial job drove you nuts and you thought, I’d rather die than go work there another day, that’s a real thing. Like, they measured I get it, it’s true. We must have purpose. We’ve all experienced the class we knew we would never use, and it was torture to be there. It was called geometry.
Remember the endless hours, obtuse angles, proofs? I mean, if hell were a choice between lake of burning sulfur or a desk desk with an endless stack of geometry problems.
That’s a tough call, right? Seriously, what was the point of that class? What did we gain from our toil? Unless you’re an architect, okay, granted. The rest of us did not need geometry at all.
So I really hope all the architects do something cool enough to make it worth it for the rest of us to have endured geometry, right? Architects, if you’re out there, I want the Willy Wonka elevator that goes sideways. I want the Harry Potter tent or the Doctor Who TARDIS that is bigger on the inside than it is on the outside. That’s what I want. And if architects can pull that off, then geometry was worth it for the rest of us.
There would have been a purpose for all of our suffering. I’m only half joking. Like, seriously. I mean, the mere fact that we are so irritated that we had to endure a pointless class, right? We’re grasping to find some reason for our toil.
What does that show us? It shows us how deeply we must find purpose in what we do. We must We are not okay being forced to sit in that class for a year unless there was some reason for it, right? We must have purpose or we go crazy. What do I gain from all my toil?
We need purpose, but there’s a problem. If we’re honest, we realize the futility of work. Is undeniable. What does the worker gain from his toil? Verse 9: nothing.
That’s the answer of Ecclesiastes. Verse 19: it’s all vanity. Other translations use the word meaningless. It’s the word for smoke or vapor. It’s elusive.
There isn’t anything real to it. We only have the illusion of meaning. Man has no advantage over the beast. Or verse 20: we all go to the same place, from All are from dust, to dust all return. He’s like, you really don’t gain anything for what you do because you end up right back where you started— dust.
Here’s the sobering reality: we come to the exact same end whether we spend our lives as titans of industry or we spend our lives laying in bed all day. We come to the exact same end. We all return to dust. Wait, it gets worse. Not only us, but everyone that we care about, no matter how much we do for them, they will come to the exact same end.
So when we say, I’m working so hard to provide for my family— I mean, great, I think we should do that— but ultimately, all that effort is going to have the exact same outcome as if we had done nothing at all. They are all going to return to dust as well. And not only them, but all of human civilization too. I mean, if we want to, like, improve the world for future generations, I think that’s awesome, noble aim. But all those future generations are going to come to the exact same end as if we had done nothing at all.
They are all going to return to dust. We have accomplished nothing, really. We cannot change the final outcome. We can’t. If we’re honest, we realize how pointless everything ultimately is.
So let’s watch our video again, and now maybe it’ll make sense.
You know what this illustration is? Is this is our lives. We start in the ditch.
We are dust. We start in the ditch. We get up. We run a little. It was fun.
And then we’re back in the ditch. That’s our life. But it’s also the life of everyone we will ever help. Help. They get up and run a little.
Maybe our kids grow or go to college, or that maybe they have a family. And then what? They are back in the ditch. To dust they return. It’s also a summary of all of human civilization, right?
We came to be somehow. We got out of the ditch. We’ve accomplished much. We run around a little. Awesome.
That we return to dust. Even if humanity develops technology to leave Earth and we colonize other planets, that would be super cool, the galaxy is going to end. It’s going to run out of energy, back to dust. There, there is no accomplishment or trophy at the end of our toil. There is nothing there.
There is nothing we can do to change the end of the story. Sure, we can run around a little out there in the field for a minute, but then it’s back to the ditch. That’s it. It’s undeniable. One thing I really appreciate, seriously, honestly really appreciate from modern atheists, if you read them, I love them, they are not trying to deny this.
They’re not trying to find meaning anymore. They admit, yeah, there is no meaning and you just need to deal with it. William Provine writes, there are no gods, no purposes, no goal-oriented forces of any kind. There is no ultimate foundation for ethics, no ultimate meaning in life, no free will for humans either. We can’t unpack all that today.
Alex Rosenberg says, what is the purpose of the universe? There is none. None. What is the meaning of life? Ditto.
Does history have any meaning or purpose? No, it’s full of sound and fury signifying nothing.
If we’re honest, it’s undeniable. We’re just sheep running back to the ditch from whence we came. So question, is that enough for you? Is that enough purpose for you? Or does it drive you crazy?
Do you feel like life and existence is one cosmic geometry class?
Is the little bit of time that you have running around in the field, all the while knowing that you’re going to end up right back in the ditch where you started, is that enough?
Jerry Cohn, evolutionary biologist, and he’s an author too, says it is enough for him. He’s an atheist. He writes, if you’re an atheist and an evolutionary biologist, what you think is, I’m lucky to have these 80-odd years. How can I make the most of my existence here? So that’s what he thinks.
That’s one story. You’re a sheep. You’ve been pulled out of the ditch. You have a little time to run, and man, you better enjoy it because that’s it. That’s one story.
Frankly, that story is not enough for me.
I doubt honestly in Jerry Cohn’s heart it’s enough for him either. Knowing, knowing your whole life, the lives of everyone you will ever love, all of human civilization is just on one giant arc back to the ditch. Sound and fury, signifying nothing.
That’s not a very good story. It should drive you crazy because God put eternity on our hearts. Verse 11: We know we are made for something more than futility. We can sense the eternal. We know we should be able to make a real difference, like a real one.
We know it, and it’s maddening to us when are faced with the undeniable reality that we can’t actually change any final outcome. We can’t change it. It’s all going to end the same no matter what. We can only change the small details of how we run around in the field before we’re ultimately back in the inevitable ditch.
That’s maddening, and it’s why we need the purpose that God provides, which is eternal.
Our efforts will eventually amount to nothing, verse 14, but what God does lasts forever, and only what God does lasts forever. So our choices are participate in what God is doing or amount to nothing at all. All, just rot and decay and be forgotten. And notice I said participate in what God is doing. I did not say our other choice is to do something for God as if we can add to what he’s doing.
It says right here we cannot add to what he’s doing, verse 14. It’s not like God is waiting on us to join him so now he can finally accomplish his mission. That’s not it. Instead, it’s like his mission is happening and we can jump into that and be part of something that lasts forever, or we can have our own tiny little temporary story, be a sheep on the way back to the ditch. Those are the 2 choices.
Unfortunately, all of humanity, you, me, everyone, has chosen to have our own tiny little temporary story instead of joining the eternal story. Back to our earliest ancestors, God said to them, trust me, listen to me, be with me. And they said, same as the rest of us, they said, no, I don’t trust you because I can’t see any good reason for what you’re saying. I’m gonna trust my own heart, follow my own instincts. I’m not gonna do what you want to do because I want to do what I want to do.
So we struck out on our own and we left the eternal story. We pledged allegiance to ourselves instead of God. We self-imposed banishment from the eternal and deceived ourselves into thinking that that was freedom.
But that is why we have such angst about our purpose. We have some kind of memory or awareness of our former status in the universe, but we’ve traded it for something far less. We know we’re supposed to be part of something that lasts forever, but we also know we’re not part of it. And that would be the end of the story if it weren’t for God, if it weren’t for Jesus. The Christian story is God comes to rescue us from our path of insignificance.
We’re blazing a trail to meaningless, and God— meaningless But God comes to get us, to bring us back to him. The eternal comes to earth. Jesus comes to earth to rescue us from our self-imposed banishment. Jesus takes the curse that we bear for forsaking God on the cross. Jesus is subjected to rot, decay, wrath, banishment from the eternal so that we can be reinstated, so that we can have our purpose again so that we can participate in what God is doing again.
That’s the Christian story. Now, how to share that in the context of conversations that you’re already having? First, maybe as a reminder, how not to share it, just based on some conversations I had this week. If someone is totally distraught and asks, what am I even doing with my life. You know, maybe work terminated them, kids moved out of the house, and it’s now difficult for them to function.
Do not come in and say, well, you just need to trust God, that’s why you’re so upset. No, goodness. If that’s what any of you are hearing when I say share your faith in the context of conversations you are already having, I’m sorry, I failed in communicating somehow. Now. So somebody’s that upset, just sit with them.
Be upset with them. Weep with those who weep. Life is on fire for them. They have an open wound. They are going to talk about it with you probably a million times if it’s that bad.
So be sensitive to that. And then as time goes on, as is appropriate, you share the hope that you have. In other words, don’t try to shortcut to gospel. We’ve called this series A Better Story.
It takes a minute to get to the end of the story. If you just let the cat, the cat out of the bag at the beginning, it’s not going to make any sense, right? They have to go along the journey with you. And it is a journey to see how the gospel intersects with all the areas of our life. We don’t pick it up instantly.
I imagine even for some of during this series, you are only now beginning to see or wrestle with connections between power, the vulnerable, purpose, etc., and what Jesus did for us. Maybe you’ve been a Christian for 40 years, but you’ve never thought about how a power conversation connects to the gospel. You’ve never thought about it. And if you’ve never thought about it, if you’ve just now started started to make those connections, you can’t expect somebody else with no background at all to be able to, like, skip all the way to the end. You have to build the concept in their mind, probably slowly, certainly compassionately, meaning you will have many conversations with your friends, neighbors, colleagues in order to comprehensively share the full greatness of Jesus, right?
It, it takes a minute to tell that story. Don’t shortcut cut it. Let it build. So maybe an example or 2 of when people might bring up the theme of purpose. Hopefully you’ve talked about other examples in your life group already, but here’s a couple.
Maybe you and your friend are joking about why Tom Brady retired from retiring.
He went back to the NFL after being retired for like 40 days, right? It’s not a very serious conversation. But people have it. People say, I guess he wasn’t satisfied rolling around in his millions of dollars, being able to live on a beach and just doing guest appearances on talk shows for the rest of his life, something, right? Or the next time the lottery is at $1 billion, people are like, what would I do with that?
I’d lay on the beach, right? So even you can laugh, right? And you can say, well, I just Do you think anyone can do that? Just do nothing and be at peace with themselves? You think that’s possible?
You know, like the Office Space guy wanted to do nothing, if that reference means anything to you. I can tell since none of you laughed, you haven’t seen that old movie. I don’t know what your friend will say, but whether your friend thinks that we’re capable of doing nothing or not, you can share your thoughts, which are probably something like, I think humans have a need to feel like what we do really matters. I think if we don’t have purpose, I think we go crazy. Your friend will probably agree.
Maybe your friend will say, yeah, when I’m working on a cool project or an important project, I feel better than if I’m working on a menial project. And you’re like, absolutely. And if what we’ve worked so hard to put together, if that ends up getting scrapped by management or tossed aside or superseded by someone else’s work, we feel pretty worthless. Like, what was the point of all those hours I just put in if you were going to scrap the project, right? See, I really think humans must be doing something that is really meaningful.
It’s just in us.
But there’s a problem. If we’re honest, we really can’t do anything that is actually meaningful. Now at this point you need to decide how deep to describe the problem to your friend, which probably depends on past conversations that you’ve had with your friend. But bottom line, we really can’t change any outcomes. Everything is going to end exactly how it would have ended if we had done nothing at all.
Sheep back to the ditch.
We can kind of trick ourselves into thinking what we do matters. We can kind of put our head in the sand and ignore the futility of reality, but the futility is there and it’s maddening. It’s so maddening, I think we know that there’s something wrong with it. Like, life can’t be so pointless. Pointless, right?
It just, it just can’t be. You can say that to your friend. Um, I bet your friend at that point would say something like, you know, I don’t really like to think about that stuff. Um, and you say, I don’t either, frankly. But here’s the question: why don’t we like to think about it?
Why would we rather put our heads in the sand and ignore reality than face the fact that we have no purpose. Why is that? Which maybe that’s the end of the conversation for that day. But then later down the road, something else comes up and you remind them. You’re like, hey, remember, we must have purpose.
We must have it. And if we’re told that we don’t have it, it drives us bonkers because we can’t live without it. Literally, we die if we don’t have purpose. They’ve It’s maddening to be reminded that we don’t have purpose. And God put that in us.
You can make the assertion, God put eternity in our hearts. We know our efforts should be able to last forever, but they don’t, and we’re upset about it, just like the author of this ancient book Ecclesiastes was upset about it. But the Christian story is that we have a way back to eternal purposes. The one with infinite worth and significance gave up his significance so we can regain ours.
That’s a pretty good story, right? And he invites us to join with him in what he is doing in the world so that then everything we do has a plotline to the eternal. Everything. Uh, we mentioned this on the video, but if you aren’t in a small group, um, the Reformers of the 16th century really, uh, unintentionally— it’s not what they were trying to do, but they did, uh, create an economic engine that changed the world, like, through their theology. They were preaching in the context of this feudal system of peasants and serfs and lords, but they showed the common person that God provides provides for the world through human effort.
Martin Luther said, when you pray for your daily bread, for instance, God doesn’t make it magically appear on your plate. God uses farmers and merchants in a system of trade which is supported by courts and protected by officers of the law. Everyone has an essential role to play, even in something as simple as how God provides daily bread. And if you have shifted your allegiance— you know, once upon a time you worked for yourself or for your own fame, which will only rot and decay and be forgotten. But now you’ve switched your allegiance to working for the one who rescued you from meaninglessness.
If you’ve done that, then you understand everything you do is with him, everything you do is in line with what he is doing, and therefore everything you do has now eternal significance. You are part of how God is feeding the world. You are part of how God is connecting the world. For all of you in tech, you are part of how God is redeeming the world. Whatever God does lasts forever, verse 14, and he’s providing for the world and healing it.
You can’t add to it, but you can join it. And 16th century people heard heard this and they started working like crazy. They start as hard as they could. They went out and were farmers and serfs and milking cows, not in order to achieve something, not in order to get fame, but because they had been given an eternal purpose to what they had— were doing. They had just been liberated out of meaninglessness.
So they, they loved work. They loved work whether their overlord was nice to them or not, that didn’t matter anymore because they knew what they were doing mattered forever because it was part of what God was doing and what God does lasts forever. That’s a better story, isn’t it? What you do matters forever. Being invited to work alongside God, that’s better than it having no meaning at all.
Being part of the eternal story instead of like scrapping for our own recognition that will ultimately fade and rot and be forgotten. It’s better. Thank God for Jesus, who was banished from the eternal so that we could be reunited to him. Let’s pray. Father, thank you for giving us a purpose.
Thank you for inviting us back into your purpose, Lord, even though we have, have chosen to blaze our own trails towards something that is meaningless and something that will rot and decay, Lord, you still chose to rescue us back into your story and have given us a role in the greatest story that has ever been told. I pray, Lord, that we can enthusiastically work, work as ones who are partnering with you, and I pray that we can enthusiastically share the purpose that you have given us, how it is a better story than meaninglessness. We pray those things in Jesus’ name.
Amen.

