The Blessing of Elders

Often, to get where we are going in life, we need some help. We need some counsel. And we definitely need correction. As it turns out, our spiritual development isn't that much different from any other type of progress. We need some help. We need some counsel. And we definitely need correction. One of the blessings of church is that God has built into the very structure of the organization the means for us to develop as Christians. This week, we'll study the blessing of elders, why they are necessary, and how they help us move forward in our relationship with God.


Sermon Transcript

Our, our scripture reading this morning is taken from 1 Peter chapter 5, verses 1 to 5. So I exhort the elders among you as a fellow elder and a witness of the sufferings of Christ, as well as a partaker in the glory that is going to be revealed. Shepherd the flock of God that is among you, exercising oversight not under compulsion but willingly, as God would have you; not for shameful gain but eagerly; not domineering over those in your charge but being examples to the flock. And when the chief shepherd appears, you will receive the unfading crown of glory. Likewise, you who are younger, be subject to the elders.

Clothe yourselves, all of you, with humility toward one another, for God opposes the proud but gives grace to the humble. May the Lord bless the reading of his word.

Thanks, John.

We can probably all give examples of great bosses, great coaches, great teachers, people who made life better for seemingly everyone they came across. They added stability to our lives, to the organization, they acted in fairness, they created prosperity, a winning record maybe, they promoted the team over themselves. We’ve all met those people. At the same time, we can probably all give examples of bosses, coaches, or teachers who seem to make everything worse. They either push too hard when they should have relaxed a bit, or they didn’t push at all when they really needed to.

Maybe they turned a blind eye to students or players or direct reports that needed to be reprimanded, and then that caused everyone to run amok, right? Or maybe they were an absent leader. They held the title of authority, but they were disconnected from those who they were supposed to be leading. So if you were in a meeting with them and they tried to act like they knew what was going on, everyone just rolled their eyes in the meeting. It’s like, when can this be over and we get back to what we’re doing and we don’t have to pay attention to this person anymore?

We could, we could all tell those stories. Even if you’re a middle schooler and you’ve never been on a team or never held a You could tell stories like that because you have seen either your parents or someone else’s parents, and you’ve seen some parents try to control every detail of their kids’ lives, or they are always yelling or demeaning of their children, or you’ve seen other parents who just flat out aren’t around, and it’s up to the kid to figure out life without any parental guidance whatsoever. And middle schoolers You already know how those kids turn out, right? You have kids in your classes right now, I’m sure, who have never faced a consequence of any kind, who haven’t had any direction ever from mom and dad, and what do those kids act like? You can say it.

They are terrible. You’ve seen it, right? On the other side, even middle schoolers, you have seen the effects of great leadership. Again, even if you’ve never been on a team, never held a job, you can look around at various parents and you can see that some parents are involved with their kids, not overbearing but involved, and they are their kids’ biggest cheerleaders and the kid knows it. But at the same time, these great parents lay down the law when needed and maybe most importantly, they’ll ask for forgiveness when they make a mistake, which of course they will make mistakes.

And the kids who have grown up in those kind of environments in general turn out way better than kids with either absent parents or helicopter parents or of course, God forbid, abusive parents. Now of course, disclaimer, there is no guarantee that good parenting will produce a great kid, no guarantee of that. But what is guaranteed, it is guaranteed that great parenting will produce a better kid than terrible parenting or absent absent parenting would have for the same kid. We all know that. And it’s true not only in families, it’s true in organizations, it’s true in sports teams.

It’s universal, right? No news to anyone. So wouldn’t it make sense that what we all know is true about leadership in every arena of life is also true in the church? Wouldn’t it make sense that good leadership is needed, it’s necessary in the church in order for us to get further along both in our corporate mission and in our personal spiritual lives? Wouldn’t that make sense?

It’s pretty intuitive, right? But often people push back on formal leadership structure in a church. And to be fair, people might have very good reasons. To push back. They may have gotten burned badly in the past, some terrible church experience.

Those happen too often. And so those people who had those experiences react by saying, and very understandably, they say, well, forget this. If this is what church is, forget church. I am never going back to organized religion. And frankly, if any of us heard all of the painful details of the story that made someone say that, we would all be sympathetic.

We would all say, wow, what you went through is inexcusable. We get it. No one should ever have to deal with that. No wonder you chose to walk away. We’d all say that if we heard the stories.

At the same time, I would contend it’s not wise to throw the baby out with the bathwater. Because if you’ve had a bad church experience, organized religion isn’t the problem. Bad organized religion is the problem. Just like having a bad boss or a bad coach doesn’t mean the entire idea of supervisors and coaches should be rejected automatically. Supervisors and coaches aren’t the problem, bad ones are.

Leadership isn’t the problem, bad leadership is, whether it’s in the church or it’s anywhere else. So if you’ve been burned in the past, we get it, but instead of abandoning like the entire concept of any sort of spiritual leadership in your life altogether, maybe find some good leadership. Of course, bad church experiences from bad leadership aren’t the only reason that people resist organized religion, is it? Some people, let’s be honest, want nothing to do with organized religion because they don’t like anyone correcting them. They have their own ideas about God and they don’t enjoy hearing how Scripture disagrees with them.

They want to be the captain of their own spiritual ship. They say, I’ll figure this Jesus thing out on my own. I’ll listen to this podcast or that author, and I will kind of take what I want from each source without any sort of accountability or discernment outside of my own preferences. And that’s not wise either, because again, I’ll point out what we all already know. If we abandon leadership in our lives, if we abandon spiritual oversight, in this instance.

We will not make it as far as we would have under good, healthy leadership. Just like any other arena in life, if you’re the kid who has had enough of your home environment and you run away and you live on the streets and try to figure it out on your own without any oversight from your parents, true, you may do better on your own than you would have under bad parents. That’s true. But you will not make it as far as you would have under good parents. Detaching from healthy oversight is never to our benefit, ever.

It is always to our detriment, whether it’s in church or it’s anywhere else. And we already know that if we think about it, which brings us to the blessing of elders in a local church. God has provided fairly detailed instructions for what the leadership of a local church is supposed to be, and it is elders. In fact, in every single instance in the New Testament when the leadership of a local church is mentioned, it is always, without exception, a plurality of elders, not one. A plurality means more than one.

It is never just one person watching over everything alone like a king. Or a pope or a dictator or a cult leader. Never see that in Scripture. It is always a collective group providing oversight, leadership, guidance, and that group is called, among other things, elders. There are various other terms used for the same role in the New Testament, like pastors, but elders are the most common.

So if you are someone who says, I don’t need to be part of a local church. I am part of the church universal, and I’ll get together with my 3 buddies and we will pray and we will sing songs and we will read scripture, and that is what I’ll do for my spiritual growth. I’m sure there are many ways that would be very encouraging for you, and there are many, many benefits to those kind of small groups, and we would encourage all of you to be part of them. But if you say, I’m going to do that instead of church instead of being part of the structure, the leadership, the guidance, the oversight of a local church. And that is what again is always seen without exception in the New Testament.

If you bail on the New Testament bottle, you will miss something. You will miss one of the blessings of church. And it’s true, I’ll concede, you may live a long, happy spiritual life without being part of a local church, just like you could develop any other skill without being officially trained. It might work, you might do okay, you could get a passing grade, totally adequate, maybe, but it will not be what it could have been. Just like any other arena of life, again, if you detach from spiritual leadership altogether, you will not make it as far as you would have under good, healthy spiritual leadership.

So today we’re studying one of the many passages in the New Testament that describes what elders do, and therefore it describes why elders are such a blessing to all of us, even those of us who are serving as elders ourselves. We benefit from having elders in our lives. And as we look at these verses, it’ll— frankly, it’ll confirm much of what is already intuitive to us about what great leaders leaders look like, which means this description of elders is not only applicable for the church, but we all need to pay attention because it’s helpful or informative for really any leadership setting. So for example, if you’re currently interviewing for a job, it would be advantageous to you to discern through the interview process somehow if your future potential supervisor is a good leader and therefore shares these characteristics because working for good leadership is great and working for bad leadership is the worst. Similarly, if you are hiring someone into a leadership role right now, you want to make sure the person you hire looks a lot like a biblical elder.

Similarly, if you’re trying to improve as a leader yourself, whether it’s at home on a team or in the classroom or at work or at church, this can help because good healthy leadership looks very similar regardless of where it is. Now, to kick us off, the metaphor often used to describe an elder in Scripture, and it is used in our verses here, is a shepherd. Elders are often compared to shepherds, and if you don’t have any familiarity with shepherds, you’ve never been on a on a farm or out in a field in Ireland, uh, don’t worry, I haven’t either, but you won’t be lost. This will still make sense to all of us. And as we study these verses, we will see the priority of shepherds, the temperament of shepherds, and then the Chief Shepherd.

The priority, the temperament, and then the Chief, all of which are tremendous blessings to us in the church. So first, the priority shepherds is the sheep.

The primary concern on the shepherd’s mind must be the sheep. We’ll look at this 2 different ways. Our verses here explain what shepherds shouldn’t prioritize, and then Jesus in a different place in Scripture shows us what shepherds should prioritize. Our verses say elders, shepherds, should not feel forced forced to serve. They should not serve under compulsion, verse 2.

In other words, they shouldn’t be guilted into it. No one should twist their arm to get them to serve. We’d never want to ask an elder, or really any leader anywhere, hey, tell me the story, how’d you end up in this role? And the leader says, well, they made me do it. I, I felt so bad, uh, they didn’t have anybody else.

I just, I kind of gave in. Which means your priority in the role is you wanted to avoid guilt? That’s the reason you’re doing it? That’s a terrible reason to do anything. It’s really, if you think about it, prioritizing yourself in a way because you didn’t want to feel bad, which means you’re thinking about you, which is the wrong priority.

Similarly, our verses say elders shouldn’t serve for a paycheck. Verse 2. No surprise, right? We, we pretty much never want someone getting out of the bed in the morning in order to get paid. Doesn’t matter the role, right?

Doctor, professional baseball player, whoever. We don’t want them to say, I’m doing this for the money. Not the best, right? That’s not what the priority should be. There really should be something else driving us, whatever you do.

Now, I’ll tell you, I’ve never actually met an elder or pastor who says they serve because it pays well. I’ve never met that guy. I know they exist, people who have somehow turned church into a lucrative enterprise, and those people might say they’re doing it for the They might, but that would be bad. We know compensation should not be the priority because it’s really just another way to prioritize yourself, your own comfort maybe, and that’s the wrong priority. That’s what our verses here say.

Don’t prioritize yourself in a leadership role. It shouldn’t be about you. So what is the right priority? What Jesus tells us, he says the priority of a shepherd should be the sheep. John chapter 10, Jesus tells us the difference between a true shepherd and someone who is just hired to watch the sheep.

Jesus says, I am the Good Shepherd. The Good Shepherd lays down his life for the sheep. The hired hand is not the shepherd and does not own the sheep. So when he— that’s the hired hand— sees the wolf coming, he abandons the sheep and runs Then the wolf attacks the flock and scatters it. The man runs away because he is a hired hand and cares nothing for the sheep.

So the difference between a shepherd and someone who is just paid to take care of the sheep is the shepherd loves the sheep and puts the sheep first, even ahead of his own needs, puts his own life on the line if necessary for the sheep. Conversely, the hired hand is just there to earn a living. He’s not there for the sheep. He’s there for himself. So if the job gets difficult, he bails, runs away, goes and does something else.

But not the shepherd. The shepherd says regardless of the cost, he’ll stay because sheep matter to him. Elders are elders, hopefully, because people matter to them. Isn’t that what we would always want in any leader? You’re interviewing someone for a role, you ask, it’s got to be one of your interview questions, what makes you want this role, right?

What you’d want to hear is, this is a good cheat if you’re interviewing right now, you can write this down, what you want to hear is, I think I can help the people that we serve and I will do everything I possibly can in order to make life best for them because they matter. That’s what we’d want to hear. And we’d want to hear it whether we are interviewing a coach, a teacher, a manager, a CEO, a husband, an elder. Because we’ve all had teachers who were just clocking in, right? It was their job.

They had to do it. They were the hired hand. And then we’ve all had teachers who taught us because they loved to see students grow. Students mattered to them. We mattered to them.

We’ve all seen CEOs who bankrupt the company while taking big bonuses for themselves. And then on the other side, maybe we’ve all seen star athletes who take lower contracts because it helps the team, because they love the team, because the team matters to them, or maybe even the fans matter to them and they want to deliver a championship. To the fans. We’ve all seen managers who scrape and claw to advance themselves. That’s common.

Maybe that’s even the default, unfortunately. But then on the other side, some of us, hopefully all of us, have been fortunate enough to have seen a manager scrape and claw to advance not themselves, but us instead, because we matter to the manager. The better leader is always the one who values team over self, others over self. It’s the leader who doesn’t walk away when times get difficult. It’s the leader who engages and seeks the welfare of the group, even if it means personal harm to him or herself, like when the wolf comes, to use the analogy Jesus does.

That’s the leader we want. That’s always the leader we want in any arena of life.

Now, how much of a difference do you think that could make in a church?

When the leaders of the church are more concerned with the health and growth of the members than they are with anything else, with their own preferences, even with their own financial security, leaders who day and night think about how to help you the most, it makes a big difference. And I’ll tell you, if you are in a church, whether it’s this one or some other one, and, and you can’t sense somehow the leadership is for you, values you, makes you feel like you matter, if you can’t, if you can’t sense that, first call them out, give them a chance, and not in some kind of passive-aggressive complain to everyone else except the people who need to change. Not that. Just really confront them. Give them a chance to repent.

And if nothing changes, don’t stick around. Don’t be part of that church. This is serious. Like, sheep should know the shepherds— shepherds, plural. There’s always more than one.

There’s always a plurality. So it’s never the responsibility of any one single elder to make every single member feel like they matter, right? So for instance, if the chairman of our elder board, Todd, doesn’t interact maybe specifically with you very often, that’s not necessarily a problem. We have 9 elders, and then plus Steve and Nate, who we should count because pastors and elders are the same in Scripture. Pastors are elders, elders are pastors.

Okay, so we have 11 really elders that share the load as a group So y’all, the people of the church, should know the shepherds, the group of the church, are for them. With 11 of us, basically, we should have visibility and input and care really in every kind of corner of the church. And you have to have that sense.

And if we’re not doing a good job, you tell us. We want to hear about it. The priority of the shepherds is the sheep.

Now, of course, showing people that they matter is not the only job of elders. There is more to it than that because it’s possible in any arena of life, a leader could make you feel ultra-affirmed, could make you feel like you really matter, but never challenge you on anything. And that’s not good for any of us either, which brings us to the temperament of shepherds. It’s neither timid nor domineering, neither timid nor domineering. Peter words it here as exercising oversight, verse 2, but at the same time not being domineering, verse 3.

It has to be both this engaging, directing, correcting, guiding, but also not abrasive. Elders have to call you out when necessary, verse 2, but they’ve got to be humbled about it, verse 5. We’re humble towards each other. If church leadership never challenges us, if they never call us out, if they never correct us, they are not qualified to be elders. Same with any leader or coach or teacher.

I mean, imagine taking golf lessons and every time you hit the ball or didn’t hit the ball. You let go of your club mid-swing and you kill a duck in the pond and the instructor says, whoo, great job, you are amazing, I should be taking lessons from you, not the other way around. That’s a terrible coach, terrible. Fire that coach immediately. Similarly, shepherds in the church need to keep us close to our doctrines.

They need to tell members when they are in error. Shepherds must, must redirect sheep in a gentle, humble, non-domineering way, of course, or they are terrible shepherds. In probably the most famous psalm in Scripture, Psalm 23, most of you have probably heard it before, but the psalmist writes, the Lord is my shepherd, I shall not want. You’ve heard this, right? But then it says, he He makes me lie down in green pastures.

He leads me beside still waters. Shepherd is never a passive role. It’s not for the timid because it’s hard to tell people they are wrong. It’s hard to hold people accountable. It’s easier just to go along to get along, but that would be a terrible shepherd.

So not only do you want to be in a church that makes you feel like you matter because you you want to be in a church where truth matters, because it does, where leadership calls errors errors, even if they need to say that you are in error, because they will, because we all need to be corrected from time to time. And if we’re not corrected, it means we’re not loved and we’re certainly not led. Now, we resist, of course, having any sort of authority like that in our lives. Me too. And the reason we resist authority is because we are rightly skeptical that leaders can easily become overbearing or domineering, always reprimanding others, riding on their high horse, acting like they have it all together while condemning everyone else.

Narcissistic savior complex, whatever else the rest, right? And if we submit to that kind of authority, it’s unwise. It’s abuse, actually. So, don’t do that. And hopefully, if we always choose elders who prioritize sheep, not themselves, it would prevent that type of unhealthy leadership.

But in the event that it doesn’t, this is where the genius of the biblical plurality of leadership really shines because no single elder ever has any authority on his own, ever. It’s only the collective group that has authority, which means no one person can ever exercise any authority without the affirmation of the entire group. It’s a type of checks and balances built into the structure that God gave us thousands of years ago. And it’s similar to how our government is really supposed to work and often does, to be fair, right? Of course, at one time or another, the different branches of our government have all tried to grab more power for themselves, but then the other branches push back, which might take a decade or 2, but it happens.

No one in our government has ever had total autonomy, ever, which is brilliant. And it’s comparable to how elders function. So if you’re in a church that has a pastor functioning as, as a king with no accountability, you may want to rethink that.

Because here’s a secret, pastors and elders are just as prone to corruption as everybody else. And if you give us unrestricted authority, we will probably take liberties that we wouldn’t have taken if we were in a plurality. So we need a plurality for us. There has been, in fact, only one shepherd that we can always trust to act in our best interest and to provide precision correction of our errors without him having any ego himself at all. There’s only one shepherd who doesn’t need any oversight or accountability.

He’s the only one who truly gave up everything for us. He’s the only one who sticks with us always regardless of the threat to himself. He’s the only one who will always chase us down no matter how far we’ve strayed. He is, as verse 4 refers to him, the Chief Shepherd. The Chief Shepherd is Jesus, of course.

He’s the one who has always prioritized us. He willingly takes on the role of our shepherd because he loves us so much, because we matter to him. In other words, he didn’t become our shepherd because someone twisted his arm. He wasn’t guilted into the role. He He wasn’t pressured.

And of course, he didn’t become our shepherd to gain any type of status or payment. In fact, he gave up status when he came to us. He chose to leave the comforts of heaven where he had infinite praise, honor, glory, and he came to earth for no reason except to bring us back to him. If you don’t feel like a priority to Jesus, this, you have missed the story because you’ve got to think about what he didn’t have in heaven. And there’s only one thing he didn’t have.

It was you. It was me. We had run away. We had sinned. We had rebelled.

He had lost us. He had everything else. He had praise, honor, comfort, glory, and he had those in infinite He had all of that, but he chose, apparently, getting us back was worth giving up everything else, everything else. Because instead of the infinite praise he had always received, he embraced rejection. Instead of eternal glory, he was despised, and then he was eventually abandoned by everyone, even his close friends.

And finally, he chose to embrace the lowest status possible in order to rescue us. Crucifixion, dying a sinner’s death where he paid the debt for our sin. He is the Good Shepherd who gave his life for the sheep so that we could be elevated, restored, that we could be reunited with God. His work on our behalf was our only hope that God himself would come redeem us. Just like the only hope of a sheep that has wandered off is that the shepherd will come find it.

The sheep is never going to get back home on its own. It needs the shepherd to come rescue us. And that’s what Jesus does. He prioritizes us in the extreme. He comes to get us back at the greatest possible cost to himself, which is why we can always trust him when he corrects us.

Because obviously, He corrects us only out of love for us. If He didn’t love us, He wouldn’t have gone to the cross in our place. That’s Jesus. He is the Chief Shepherd. And elders of a local church, which are sometimes called undershepherds, are successful in their role only to the extent that they display the Chief Shepherd through their actions.

Obviously, elders can’t die in someone’s place to redeem them to God like Jesus does, but the idea of spending our lives to elevate the church, not to elevate ourselves, that is the task of elders. Being an elder or pastor, it is not a monthly commitment to attend a meeting, though we do have those, and we have one today, so you can pray for us. But that’s not really what it is. It’s not even a career. It’s a lifestyle.

It’s putting the sheep’s needs above our own always, which is not prestigious. It can’t be prestigious. It can’t be an ego builder. Like, if pastors or elders try to make the role an ego builder, it just subverts everything they’re trying to do. Because again, we’re trying to display Jesus and who he is through everything we do, and we can’t display someone who gave up his status for the sake of others while trying to accumulate status for ourselves.

That would be self-defeating. So it’s got to be all for others all the time. That’s the role. That’s the only way to do it. Now, wouldn’t you love to be in a church where the elders had that kind of attitude toward you?

Do everything within their power to elevate you, sacrifice for you, defend you against harm, whether it is harmful doctrine or something else. Never thinking of their own prestige. Wouldn’t that be great?

I bet if you saw a church like that, you’d never complain about organized religion again.

Instead, you’d say organized religion done properly under Christlike leadership is the greatest experience of my life, is a tremendous blessing, if you have the right people leading it. And we pray that’s what you find here. I promise it’s what we’re aiming for, even though we will fall short of it. We will, we will fall short of that. We do fall short of that.

But when we fall short, we will repent, because more than anything else, we want to show you the Chief Shepherd and what He is like because He really is our only hope.

Let’s pray.

Father, thank You for Jesus and the model that He is and for filling us with Him in such a way that we are then enabled to serve others, that You were selfless, Lord. We don’t have to look out for ourselves because we know you already have that covered. So Lord, I pray that we would all grow in leadership, that we would grow in our concern for others, whoever it is that, that we kind of have influence into their lives. May we grow in love for them, Lord. May we be neither timid nor domineering, but may we always point people to you and your truth.

Give us the courage, give us the opportunity, and transform us to be, to be those kind of people in, in whatever circle that we’re in. Lord, we pray those things in Jesus’ name. Amen.