What Makes Leaders Great?

1 Corinthians 4 and 9

Nothing can make us desire great leaders quite as quickly as experiencing bad ones. But what exactly makes the difference? Are there certain qualities that great leaders share? Does God have a design for leadership? This week, we’ll study two contrasting styles of leadership, the role each of us can play regardless of our official title, and the ultimate litmus test for any leader.


Sermon Transcript

This is how one should regard us, as servants of Christ and stewards of the mysteries of God. Moreover, it is required of stewards that they be found faithful. I have applied all these things to myself and Apollos for your benefit, brothers, that you may learn by us not to go beyond what is written, that none of you may be puffed up in favor of one against another. For who sees anything different in you? What do you have that you did not receive?

If then you received it, why do you boast as if you did not receive receive it. To the present hour we hunger and thirst, we are poorly dressed and buffeted and homeless, and we labor, working with our hands. When revived, we bless; when persecuted, we endure; when slandered, we entreat. We have become and are still like the scum of the world, the refuse of all things. I do not write these things to make you ashamed, but to admonish you as my beloved children.

For though you have countless guides in Christ, you do not have many fathers. For I became your father in Christ Jesus through the gospel. I urge you then, be imitators of me. That is why I sent you Timothy, my beloved and faithful child in the Lord, to remind you of my ways in Christ as I teach them everywhere in every church. This is my defense to those who would examine me: do we not have the right to eat and Do we— if we have sown spiritual things among you, is it too much if we reap material things for you?

If others share this right claim on you, do not we even more? Do we not know that those— do you not know that those who are employed in the temple service get their food from the temple, and those who serve at the altar share in the sacrificial offerings? In the same way, the Lord commanded that those who proclaim the gospel should get their living by the gospel. But I have made no use of any of these rights, nor am I writing these things to ensure such provision. For though I am free from all, I have made myself a servant to all, that I might win more of them.

To the Jews, I became a Jew in order to win Jews. To the weak, I became weak, that I might win the weak. The weak. I have become all things to all people, that by all means I might save some. I do it all for the sake of the gospel, that I might share with them in its blessings.

We have probably all witnessed organizations teams, families, governments with healthy cultures, healthy leadership. We have all probably witnessed organizations, teams, families, governments with unhealthy cultures, unhealthy leadership. Some of us have seen a transition transition from one of those extremes to the other. You know, new leadership came in at work or at church or with your favorite sports franchise, right? And when, when new leadership came in, the organization dramatically changed even though the stated goals were basically the same as they had always been.

You know, your company company still wanted to sell the same product to the same customers. Your sports team still wanted to win games. Your church still hoped to reach its community for Christ, and it’s still taught out of the same Bible, right? The stated purpose or objective of the organization didn’t change, but with new leadership, suddenly everything felt different. Maybe people had a new enthusiasm to come work or to church, or they were motivated to put in the extra practice time when before they always checked out early, or team members started getting along with one another who had never gotten along before, or the problematic people stopped being problematic simply because leadership changed.

Some of us have seen that, but what is that? That? Why do some leaders add to organizational health and other leaders seem to destroy it? What makes the difference, right? I mean, everyone’s trying to be great, but not everyone is.

Why?

We’re, uh, continuing our study of Paul’s ancient letter to the Corinthians. We’ve been in this for several months. We will be all the way toward Christmas. And today we’re looking at 2 different passages that contrast different types of leaders. Now Paul is referring to leadership in the church, pastors, elders, and at the time he was writing, even apostles.

You know, the proper way for church leaders to lead, which granted, most of us in this room are pastors or elders. But that does not mean that we can’t benefit from his instructions regarding leadership. In fact, we all need to heed his counsel for at least 2 reasons. One, because leadership principles are transferable. You know, what makes a good leader in the church is the same thing that makes a good leader anywhere else.

And conversely, the type of leadership that is toxic in the church is also toxic anywhere else. Human nature is human nature, organizational behavior is organizational behavior, teams are teams, and we are all on some kind of team. Whether we are part of a family, part of a neighborhood, or, you know, how we interact with coworkers, if we’re in a classroom, or just with our group of friends, we are all part of some group some way aware, and I’m sure we would all prefer for that group to be healthy. We want the group dynamics to add value to our lives and to the lives of everyone else. We don’t want that group to be toxic.

So we need to pay attention to Paul because we have the power to influence any of those groups for good. That doesn’t matter if we are the official leader or not, or even if the group has an official leader. I mean, your friend group probably never nominated a captain, whereas your work group certainly has someone in charge. But regardless of whether the group has a chain of command or regardless of if you’re at the top of it, there are timeless principles for how any of us can participate in any group so as to make it better. And conversely, there are ways any of us can participate in any group so as to make it worse.

All of us have that power. We all have the power of leadership. So that’s one reason Paul’s instructions regarding church leadership are relevant to all of us. The other reason is because we are all part of this church and we want this church to be healthy. We want every group in this church to be healthy.

Most of us are in some kind of group, whether it’s a life group or our worship ministry team or kids ministry or women’s ministry or missions committee, on and on. Most of us are in a group. So how is it we can positively influence those groups? And then more broadly, you, you may not know this if you haven’t been around very long, but, uh, our congregation at large is responsible for selecting our elders. Our elders are the ones who make all the big decisions to make sure we stay on track.

They’re men from our congregation nominated and voted on by the people of our congregation, which means it would be helpful to know what kind of character and, you know, instincts you’re looking for when you are looking for elders, because otherwise, you know, you may get the wrong kind of people steering the ship, and we don’t want that. Okay, so Paul’s instruction about church leadership is helpful to all of us regardless of our age, regardless of our title. We all need this wisdom. So as we look at this text for today, we will see, uh, the mark of poor leadership, the marks of great leadership, and then the ultimate leadership litmus test. The mark of poor leadership, the marks of great leadership, and then the ultimate leadership litmus test.

So first, the mark of poor leadership. It’s promotion of self. Now modern leadership books, they’re going to name a whole bunch of other traits of poor leadership, but they usually include this one. Paul words it as being puffed up against each other, verse 6, boasting over each other, verse 7. So apparently some people in the church thought they were better than others, either because of their status in society or perhaps because of certain gifts or abilities or talents.

So some of them thought, I deserve more recognition. I deserve the praise. They’re elevating themselves. They’re seeing themselves as more important. They’re puffed up, right?

Caring about themselves more than caring about the needs of the overall group or caring about the mission at large. So like on a football team, right? Sometimes you have players who don’t care so much whether the team wins or loses, they just want to make sure they look good. It’s self-aggrandizing, it’s puffed up. Then Paul actually addresses the same issue again in his second letter to the Corinthians, chapter 11, and he calls out certain Christian teachers who seem to fly into Corinth, they draw a big crowd, they pick up a paycheck, and then they keep going.

Going, something like celebrity teachers, they’re just using Jesus to create a career for themselves but their real passion is their own platform. Paul says that’s puffed up, that’s elevating yourself, not that there’s anything wrong with getting paid for your efforts in any sphere, right? Paul makes it crystal clear in our passage that laborers deserve wages, You know, we didn’t read this part, but he uses a metaphor of the ox plowing the field needs to eat. And if you don’t feed your ox who plows your field, pretty soon you won’t have an ox. It’s going to make it much harder to plow your field.

So every organization needs to compensate leaders what those leaders are worth. But there are people in any industry industry, and you can tell they are not concerned about the mission of the organization. They are not really concerned about their teammates. The only reason they enlisted into the cause was for themselves.

They want— the reason they want to lead people is because they want to be on top of the pile, which makes them very concerned about getting credit, getting glory, they’re puffed up. This is the whole reason they’re there. So Paul warns, first of all, don’t be like that. Don’t— but also don’t follow those kind of leaders. In the context of church, Paul is saying even if certain leaders sound great, even if they say true things, even if they’ve helped your relationship with God, which they probably have if they’re gifted leaders, but if their goal is to platform themselves, they are not the people to follow.

They are poor leaders. Those kind of leaders will ruin the team. Imagine, you can imagine a football team again, and you’ll get lots of football references today because, hi, I’m Dan, and I love college football, and ’tis the season. But just imagine on On a football team, if players spend their energy worrying about how often they get the ball, or if they spend their energy worrying if they have the best stats, or if they will get the MVP, or making sure they avoid blame if they ever lose, if any of that is the focus instead of making sure the mission is accomplished, which is win the game, the mission won’t be accomplished very often. Often there’s a player earlier this season, offensive player, incredible talent, but his team lost a game.

And to be fair to this guy, the team lost the game largely because their defense couldn’t stop the other team’s offense, right? So when they interviewed our offensive player, the great player, after the game, he said, it’s not my fault we lost. I did my part, and hey, I can’t play offense and defense.

His concern was, how do I look? How do I make sure my image remains bright and shiny? Does everyone here know that I did well? Because no blame is going to come on me. I got to look good.

He’s puffed up. How do you think that attitude is going to play in the locker room? How do you think the rest of the team is going to respond to those comments? It doesn’t help anything. Being puffed up doesn’t help anything.

It’s not going to motivate the defense to be better. And the great irony is if you try to promote yourself like that, you end up demoting yourself. Instead of looking good, you look bad. You look petty.

And then worse than ruining yourself, you’re going to ruin the whole team that you’re part of, whether it’s your family, a work team, church, it’s universal. Elevating self, trying to puff yourself up, making sure you get yours is not the way. It’s a mark of poor leadership. Okay. So if that’s poor leadership, what are the marks of great leadership?

Paul has 3 in this passage. You’ll find more in Ephesians. Any leadership literature, but Paul only covers 3, and he lists humble stewardship, laboring for others, gracious under criticism. Humble stewardship, laboring for others, gracious under criticism. We’ll take those one at a time.

So Paul starts by defining leadership as a type of stewardship, verse 1. So whatever gives you influence in a group, that was granted to you. Whatever title you carry, that was granted to you, and it was less something that you achieved and more something that you received. In other words, you didn’t climb to the top of some mountain by yourself in order to have it. It was more of a gift given to you, probably by many others.

Paul asks, verse 7, what do you have that you didn’t receive?

The answer is nothing. And if it was something you received instead of achieved, then how can you boast about it? How can you puff yourself up over something that you didn’t create? Paul pushes against the idea of a self-made success story. Because there really isn’t such a thing as a self-made success story.

That doesn’t mean you weren’t involved in whatever process it was that got you to where you are. Of course, of course you were involved, but more so, it was given to you. Think about your talents that you have, what you’re naturally good at. You didn’t build those in a lab. Your intellect, You didn’t create your IQ or the location and time period in which you were born.

You know, for our computer engineers in here, I dare say if you were born 200 years ago, your skills at coding wouldn’t have paid off, right? You didn’t choose where you’re living, the time period you live in, the gifts you have, right? No, you didn’t achieve any of that. Even things like your willpower or your determination. If you’re like, well, if I was born 200 years ago, sure, computer programming wouldn’t have helped, but I figured out something else to do because I have that drive within me.

All right, fine. You can’t claim total credit for that either. It was probably instilled in you somehow, either from a positive example or a negative example. I reckon recognize in my own life a lot of my willpower probably comes from witnessing my dad who would never quit on a task. He would do whatever it took to get the job done, work the problem until it was solved no matter what, keep pushing.

If it takes forever, fine, keep pushing. I grew up with that. So I thought, oh, this is just what life is. And I’m grateful I don’t have that much drive, but I’m grateful at least some of his sheer relentlessness was imprinted on me. But what if I had a dad who always gave up when it got hard?

What if I had a dad who wasn’t there at all?

What influence would that have had on me? Right? So I can see even in my own experience everything about me. Even things like my determination— okay, yes, it’s mine, but it’s not entirely mine. It was given to me.

And that is true with whatever gifts or abilities, um, or so-called achievements that we have. We wouldn’t be where we are without the input, the investment, and the work of many other people. We do not get to where we are alone. We are not totally self-made, and therefore we cannot brag. So another football example, I’ll brag on my most beloved college football team and really one of the most beloved players of all time, Archie Griffin, who played for Ohio State in the 1970s.

He is still to this day the only person to win the Heisman Trophy twice, so he stands alone. At least in that category. You know, he’s on top of that pyramid in college football, which means he could easily say, I’m the greatest ever, look at what I did, my achievement is unmatched, you know, everyone come bask in my glory. He could be puffed up, he could be, but he isn’t. Even today whenever he is interviewed and I, you know, to my shame I guess I’ve listened to way too many interviews and they ask him, what is it like to be the only person to win the trophy twice?

Or how did you do it? Or why do you think this record still stands 50 years later? He always says every time, he says it was my offensive line. They won the award for me. I could not have done it without them.

My 2 Heisman Trophies really belong to those guys who blocked for me up front. He understands he would not be where he is without other people. And listen, I, I don’t care what kind of team you’re on, even if it’s just your family, right? You always have an offensive line. There’s always those people Sure, you had a role in the process, okay?

Just like Archie was the one who carried the ball, he’s involved, but even he is not self-made.

There is no such thing as self-made. So have humility in whatever it is that you have been given that has given you any amount of influence in somebody else’s life, right? And one of the best-selling leadership books ever, Good to Great, Jim Collins. He details the characteristics of leaders who guide their organization to unprecedented success. And one of the characteristics that he names, totally secular book, is humility.

It’s instead of seeking personal glory, he found the most successful leaders always, always try to identify the other people on their team who contributed to the success. The successful leaders name and celebrate the others who made it possible. And you can see why that would create effective teams, because if you have a leader always celebrating the contributions of other team members, then those other team members will see— will feel seen and appreciated, which makes them more motivated, makes the team more unified, On and on, right? So that’s one mark of great leadership, humble stewardship. Everything you have has been given to you.

Second marker is laboring for others. Paul describes the role of the leader really as someone who bends over backward for the benefit of others. In Paul’s case, he’s even working without getting paid. That’s really working for others. But maybe even more kind of foundational to that, maybe what led him to say, no, don’t pay me, is his example of putting his own preferences on the back burner so that others can have what they need.

He writes, and many of you could quote this or part of this, starting in verse 19, he says, I have made myself a servant to all that I might win more of them. To the Jews I became a Jew, in order to win Jews. To those under the law, I became as one under the law. To those outside the law, I became as one outside the law. To the weak, I became weak that I might win the weak.

I have become all things to all people that I might save some. Which does not mean that he’s being fake. His goal is not to fit in or appease others, not his goal. He says what his goal is. His goal is to be a servant of all.

His goal is to work for others, for the benefit of others. In order to do that, he figures out what the group needs, which is different depending on what group you’re in, and then he’s there to do that. He’s there to contribute whatever the need is. He’s not there for himself. And I’ll tell you, if other team members see that you are there for them or for the mission, then they will follow you.

They will respect you. They will see you as a leader. You know, it’s the opposite of making much of yourself, which was the mark of poor leadership. It’s being there for others, being there for the mission. I’ll give you another football example.

Saquon Barkley, running back for the Philadelphia Eagles, earlier this season one game, uh, he was on the verge of a career-high day in rushing yards. He was about to break his own single-game record, but his team was winning by so much that it didn’t make sense for him, their star running back, to stay in the game. Because if he stays in the game, maybe he would get hurt, which would be worse for the team later on. So Barkley is on the bench. But one of the stat guys realizes, hey, Barkley only needs a few more yards to set his own personal record for a single game.

So the coach comes over, the stat guy talks to the coach, coach comes over and says, hey, we weren’t going to put you back in because we’re winning by so much, but we can put you in because if we do, you will set a new personal single-day record. So you want to go back in? And Barkley says, no, let the other guys get a chance to play. Those other guys don’t always get in the game. They don’t always get the opportunities that I do to be on the field, and they should go in because it matters to them.

They should play.

His focus is the group, right? The mission, his team members. It’s not himself. Not his glory. Would it have been okay to go in?

Sure.

But great leaders are there for others, for the goals of the organization. They labor for others. Their focus is others, not self.

So that was the second marker, labor for others way above yourself. Now, the last marker of great leadership in this passage is gracious under correction. Criticism. Paul faced extreme criticism, which he mentions in our verses. He’s persecuted, slandered.

He says he’s— it’s as if he’s the scum of the world, refuse of all things. That’s pretty extreme, right? It’s tough for him. It’s not easy being a Christian in 1st century Rome, especially one as visible as Paul was. Every power structure was against him— religious leaders, politicians, philosophers in the academy.

There’s no institution that respected him. There’s no safe haven in the wider world, so he’s constantly under pressure. Even his friends in the church sphere wouldn’t always publicly support him. You know, if he had social media, when he opened it up and looked at his profile, all the mentions of him would be negative. It’s not like today who, you know, whatever leaders say, about half of the the social people on social media are going to agree with you, right?

Paul’s day, he would have had zero public support, had no likes from the power brokers of his world. That’s tough. But even when he was criticized, as often as it was, he didn’t attack back. Instead, he blessed those who cursed him. He says, when reviled, we bless.

When slandered, we treat, which is exactly what Jesus commands his followers to do. Luke 6:28, bless those who curse you, right, or persecute you. It’s not optional for Christians. Bless those who curse you, not optional. But it is so rare to see someone do that.

So, so rare to see someone get berated in a meeting by a boss or coworker coworker, at home by a spouse. So rare for someone to get attacked and then that person to turn around and say something encouraging to the attackers.

You almost never see anyone do that outside of Ted Lasso. If you don’t know that reference, ask somebody who just chuckled. But it’s rare Even amongst professing Christians, almost all of us always try to find an excuse to justify responding to an attack with an attack.

Because it seems like you need to verbally punch back if you want to keep your followers, if you want to protect your reputation, right? You’re like, I’ll get crushed if I don’t fight back, right? Because he seems strong as a leader. You think, I’ve got to hit back twice as hard as I’ve been hit.

But Paul says, and Jesus before him says, no, that’s not how we do it. We bless those who persecute us. We encourage those who slander us. And I’ll tell you, blessing those who curse you, it is a strange, but it is a stronger kind of strength. Strength.

Turns out you don’t need to be harsh in order to be strong.

If someone verbally assaults you and you respond to that person with blessing, they almost don’t know what to do with it, right? It’s disarming.

And then your followers, anyone who sees you respond to an attack like that, your followers, instead of leaving you, they become more— even more endeared to you. It draws people to you in a totally different way than if you overpower your attacker. And it’s a mark of great leadership, gracious under criticism. So there you have it, marks of great leadership in this passage where humble stewardship, laboring for others, gracious under criticism. Now finally, the ultimate leadership litmus test, or you could say, where did Paul get these ideas?

The ultimate leadership test is, are we leading like Jesus? Paul gets these leadership ideas from Jesus. Verse 16 of our passage, Paul says, imitate him. He tells— imitate me, he tells the Corinthians.

Imitate how I lead. Lead. And then later, this chapter 11, we’ll get there eventually, Paul further clarifies. He says, imitate me as I imitate Christ. In other words, Paul didn’t come up with these ideas on his own.

He learned them from watching Jesus. The ultimate test if we are leading correctly is if we can say to the members of our team, members of our family, members at work, members of the church, the ultimate test is if we can say, imitate me as I imitate Christ. As Jesus didn’t use his glory to elevate himself but instead used his glory to elevate others, as Jesus didn’t come to be served but instead came to serve, so I labor for others. As Jesus, even on the cross, didn’t turn to attack his accusers but Jesus said, Father, forgive them for they know not what they do. You know, as Jesus is the ultimate great leader, humble in stewardship, laboring for others, gracious under criticism, Paul says, that’s what I’m shooting for.

Join me in shooting for that. Imitate me as I imitate Christ. Which I imagine for all of us, right, when we hear that Jesus is the standard, we immediately recognize, or we should recognize, We’re not anywhere close, right? I mean, how would you like for that to be the single metric on your performance review? There’s only one question on your year-end evaluation, and it is, to what percentage did you— can you say, imitate me as I imitate Christ?

I mean, for any of us, I assume we realize, or we should, we have a lot of room to grow. Right? We don’t lead anywhere near in our homes and our— with our coworkers at church, we don’t lead anywhere near how Jesus leads. And if you realize that, if you realize how far you’re falling short, good news, you’re already growing.

Because the odd thing about Christian growth is that it doesn’t so much happen by trying harder and harder and harder, though effort is certainly part of it. But Christian growth primarily happens by admitting I fall short, but I’m going to trust the one who is sufficient for me. Where I was selfish in leadership, he is selfless. Where I am self-promoting, he is self-humiliating, choosing to go to the cross in my place. Where, where I want to be served, he serves.

Where I want to blame others, he was blamed for me. He took the chastisement for my sin. The more we lean into his work on our behalf, then the more we grow to be like him. That’s how we progress as leaders. That’s how we progress as Christians.

So may we all freely admit that we are not yet the type of leaders who can at least fully say, imitate me as I imitate Christ. But may we seek him that it may be so, trusting one day he will complete the work that he began in us and we will spend eternity on a team, on a team where everyone forgets about themselves. We’ll be on a team where everyone elevates others, and we’ll be on a team where everyone praises the one who redeemed us from every ounce of our sin. Let’s pray and start praising him now. Father, thank you for Christ.

Thank you for the type of leader that you are.

Thank You that You gave up everything that we may be elevated. Thank You for modeling for us what leadership is, Lord. But Lord, transform us. We fall short. We are not gracious under criticism.

We labor for ourselves so often, Lord, and we want the glory so often. But help us, but show us the freedom And, and how you want us to be, and give us the strength to follow as we trust what you have already done. We pray all those things in Jesus’ name. Amen.