Sermon Transcript
The words of the teacher, son of David, king in Jerusalem. Meaningless, meaningless, says the teacher, utterly meaningless. Everything is meaningless. What do people gain from all their labors at which they toil under the sun? I applied my mind to study and to explore by wisdom all that is done under the heavens.
What a heavy burden God has laid on mankind. I have seen all the things that are done under the sun. All of them are meaningless, a chasing after the wind. So I hated life because the work that is done under the sun was grievous to me. All of it is meaningless, a chasing after the wind.
I hated all the things I had toiled for under the sun because I must leave them to the one who comes after me, and who knows whether that person will be wise or foolish? Yet they will have control over all the fruit of my toil into which I have poured my effort and skill. Skill under the sun. This too is meaningless. So my heart began to despair over all my toilsome labor under the sun.
For a person may labor with wisdom, knowledge, and skill, and then they must leave all they own to another who has not toiled for it. This too is meaningless and a great misfortune. What do people get for all the toil and anxious striving with which they labor under the sun? All their days their work is grief and pain. Even at night their minds do not rest.
This too is meaningless. A person can do nothing better than to eat and drink and find satisfaction in their own toil. This too I see is from the hand of God, for without him who can eat or find enjoyment? To the person who pleases him, God gives wisdom, knowledge, and happiness. But to the sinner he gives the task of gathering and storing up wealth to hand it over to the one who pleases God.
This too is meaningless, a chasing after the wind.
Thank you, Mei-Lyn. I was talking to Austin this week, just, actually it was probably yesterday morning. He reminded me that several weeks ago I stood up here and I introduced our summer series, This Is My Story, And I said, this was like when you have a show you really like on Netflix and you watch it and you get to the end, and then you have to wait till the next year and then the new season drops. And that was the beginning of this, ’cause this was season 3 of Bridges Community Church’s This Is My Story. Well, if that was when the season dropped, today is the long-awaited season finale.
And today you will not believe the twists and the turns. The loose ends will be tied up, but the cliffhanger will just leave you waiting for next summer. I’m just kidding. Today we have a huge treat, the moment many of us have been waiting for. Today our speaker is my new friend, coworker, and one of our new pastors on staff.
Would you please help me welcome up to share his story, Pastor Joshua Smith.
Thank you, Nate. Thanks, man. Hey, I want to say a word of prayer for you, and then I’m excited to hear your story. Here we go. Let’s do it.
Uh, Lord God, I thank you for Joshua. We have been praying for Joshua for a long time, and he is here. We were praying for him before we even knew who it was, and now Joshua and Katie and their beautiful children are here in the Silicon Valley, here serving at Bridges Community Church, and we are so grateful and we are excited. God, today as he shares his story, I pray that this story, which is truly your story that he is living and experiencing, I pray that this inspires, encourages, and teaches each of us in incredible ways. God, I pray that through this story we are drawn in near to you, that we hear your word, we hear the gospel message, and we come to know you more clearly each and every day.
God, we love you, we thank you. In Jesus’ name I pray, amen. Amen. Thank you, Nate. Well, it is good to be up here.
It’s a tremendous honor to be sharing part of my story and to be sharing God’s word with you this morning. Like Nate said, I am the new associate pastor here, and it has been so many opened and closed doors to get here. And the story that I’m going to share with you, the format is going to be a little different than the preceding stories. It’s going to be closer to kind of a traditional sermon that I’m going to tell you bits and parts that resound with me and that capture part of my story. But before we get to that, I want to extend a deep thank you, a hearty thank you to you all.
You know, we’ve traveled 2,000 miles to get here from Houston, Texas, and there’s been lots of anxiety, there’s been lots of anticipation, and you all have been the hands and feet of Jesus to my wife Katie and my family. Our stuff was delayed. We arrived here and our stuff was delayed for 8 days. People came, had room and sleeping arrangements set up, even some stuff in the refrigerator. When our stuff did arrive, the young adults came over and helped mostly to watch our kids so that we could unpack.
And that was so, so helpful, and many smiles and many covered dishes and meals have been the extension of Jesus’s love, and we have felt so welcomed. So thank you for that. We are getting to— getting— wow, word twist there. We are getting— looking forward to getting to know more of you as we integrate here to doing ministry in Silicon Valley. Now, as we told people that we’re moving to Silicon Valley, sometimes people will be like, oh my goodness, The weather is beautiful, and indeed it is.
If you’ve ever been to Houston, the heat is oppressive, okay? You’re walking through the air cutting it like a butter knife because not only is it hotter, but it’s so, so humid. And so we’ve been so appreciative of the beautiful. And when you all say, oh gosh, it’s a heat wave’s coming through, it’s 82, you’ve not seen anything yet, okay? Like, oh, look at these pansies here in Silicon Valley.
And not only do you have great weather here, you have great geological formations. You got these hills and just a little further away, the mountains. And we’re so eager to experience what it has to offer. But people don’t really move to Silicon Valley in order to live and to appreciate those things. People move to Silicon Valley in order to work.
And in fact, there’s kind of a causal connection there. You can’t live here unless you continue to work because you won’t be able to survive. The amenities and the weather and the opportunities all pale in comparison to the professional opportunities that are here in the Bay Area. We come here to work. And we as Americans, we kind of have a love-hate relationship with work.
Some of us, some in our culture think that work is what life is all about. I think it was Sam Walton, the founder and the CEO for many years of Walmart. He was being driven around as he would do to check on his stores, to give his stores kind of performance reviews. And he had been diagnosed with cancer, a cancer that would eventually take his life. And his driver is driving around and says, Mr. Walton, don’t you want to, like, get out and start living real life?
Without missing a beat, he said, this is real life. Kind of capturing that idea that work simply is what life is all about, and it provides that kind of deep meaning that we’re after in life. But there’s also this other stream in our culture. This kind of anti-work or hating work, that really work, we have to do it, especially if you live in Silicon Valley, but it kind of gets in the way of the things that matter most in life. It is at least a distraction or maybe even a detraction to the things that give us deep meaning and value.
Tim Ferriss’ The 4-Hour Workweek kind of captures this idea. Wouldn’t that be nice? Or the FIRE method, F-I-R-E. E, financial independence, retire early, kind of capture this anti-work idea. Well, the preacher, as he calls himself, or the teacher that he calls himself here in the NIV, also has different views of work. And they don’t line up directly with the love-hate relationship that I just mentioned in our culture, but they give kind of 3 different ways that we can approach work and what that will mean for the meaning that we find in our activities, but also the meaning that we find in our life.
And we’ll be looking at those as we go through the sermon today. And one of the reasons why that I chose Ecclesiastes is because it has something to say to us and something to both affirm and critique about our views of work. But also, because we’re in this series of My Story, I chose it because this is my personal favorite book of the Bible. It has been speaking to me since a year after my conversion, and it continues to speak to me even in the preparation for this sermon. But it also captures something, something important that we need to hear in our culture’s quest for meaning and the meaning that we put in our vocations.
So, I present to you, and you’ll see this on your outline, 3 different ways, and these will be our points, 3 different ways that the teacher comes at and views work. He’s going to view work in itself, or work as work, work as a legacy, and then work as a gift. Work in itself, work as a legacy, and work as a gift. So, we start with work in itself, and I need to set up part of— we’re kind of jumping into the middle of Ecclesiastes, so I need to kind of prime you on what’s going on here. Ecclesiastes is a despairing man, this teacher or preacher as he calls himself, and he’s come to the end of his life, and he’s asking, Has any of it been worth it?
Is anything in my life pursuits big enough in order to hold the kind of meaning that my heart longs for? He’s doing a thought experiment. He’s going to say, I’m going to look at these candidates for meaning in life, and I’m going to see whether they can satisfy the deep longing and meaning that my heart has without God. Now, he mentions God, and Malin, when she read, mentions in the Scriptures here at least 2 times. But what he’s doing is he’s going to say, let’s imagine that God does not exist, or if He does exist, He doesn’t really care about us.
Are these things in our life big enough to hold and to give us meaning that we desperately desire. And he goes through some very convincing candidates. He looks at wisdom, he looks— then he looks at wisdom over folly, he looks at pleasure, he looks at knowledge, he looks at achievement, and the consideration that we are looking at today, he considers work. Is work under the sun big enough for the human heart? That’s the question he’s asking.
No matter what side of the issue of either love or hate work that you are on, you cannot deny the immense importance of work and what it plays in giving us meaning and giving us opportunities for meaning in our life. If you’re on the lover’s side, you think work work is what life is all about, it is the meaning, just like Mr. Walton said. But if you’re on the hater side, you think it kind of gets in the way of those most valuable things in life, then it at least is a vehicle so that you can get to those meaningful things. No matter what our view of work is and the meaning that we find in life, who can deny the kind of satisfaction that you get when you finish a difficult task, and you do a job well done. There’s something very rewarding about that.
It’s undeniable that here in Silicon Valley, work under the sun is precisely what many of you or your coworkers or neighbors— it’s precisely how they view work. Jobs in Silicon Valley are highly sought after. People move from long, far away in order to obtain these occupations. It’s undeniable, whether you hold this view or not, that at least the people that you’re passing in your neighborhoods and on the highways and that you work with view work as an immense source of meaning under the sun. Most people, as you know, in the Bay Area don’t really believe in the God of the Bible and place a huge importance of— and huge value on work under the sun.
Maybe it’s not the only thing, but it’s a huge source of meaning. So the question that we are presented with, that the teacher presents us with from the Scriptures is, does work provide meaning under the sun? There’s been a good deal of research on this topic. One professor, Garrett Potts, he is a professor At the University of South Florida, he works at— in the intersection, his research between business and spirituality. And his research asks this question: why do people pick the vocations that they do?
Why do people pick the career paths that they do? And what he finds in his great book on the topic is that for many of us, especially my generation and the generation coming after me, work provides A deep sense of meaning. Does that sound familiar? A deep sense of meaning, personal fulfillment, and even we demand from work a kind of therapeutic happiness.
In his scholarly research, he points out that this view, people who have this view, work doesn’t deliver. Now, you may be like, well, it’s about time they figured out that. They should come into my work on Monday. They would figure it out. Very quickly that it doesn’t provide the meaning for life.
In one particular evidence that he uses for this, he follows 407 young professionals who have this view of demanding from work that it give them some type of deep meaning and therapeutic happiness and found that they were more likely to have negative views of themselves than the control group. Now, the Bible gives a much more devastating assessment of work under the sun. Than even this.
Not only negative views of yourself, perhaps, like Potts’ research suggests, but work under the sun leads to a devastating loss of meaning. Look at verse 17 in chapter 2. He says, so I hated life. I’m in chapter 2, verse 17. So I hated life because the work that is done under the sun was grievous to me.
All of it is meaningless, a chasing after the wind. Why? Why is there such a devastating loss of meaning? Here is a biblical principle that the teacher is hinting at. If work does not matter in the grand scheme of things, that is above the sun, then it does not have the kind of meaning that our hearts long for.
Let me say that again. If work does not matter in the grand scheme of things, that is above the sun, then it does not have the kind of meaning that our hearts ache for. If we had time and we were going through Ecclesiastes, we would see in chapter 3, verse 11, that the teacher says that God has planted eternity in man’s heart, that we intrinsically long for things to matter beyond ourselves. If work— it’s as if he’s saying if work does not echo in eternity, then it’s not going to resound or have meaning now. Now, that’s the biblical view.
What many in our culture are going to respond to, what they’re going to respond to this is like, okay, Yes, if work doesn’t matter somehow above the sun, I don’t really believe in God, but it matters to me. These projects, these endeavors, this vocation matters to me, and that’s enough.
But is it enough? Is it enough to just matter? Are we truly satisfied with things mattering only on the individual level. Let me give you an example of why I think this is not the case, perhaps a common experience in the Silicon Valley traffic. You get into a fender bender.
So there you are going along the freeway and you get in a fender bender, so much so that you have to fill out a report and you have to call the police and so on. You’re kind of shaken up. You like this car. Okay? You didn’t like this happening, but everybody’s okay.
Everybody’s safe. Your good friend is on the same freeway and passes you and pulls off and like, oh, I need to go and see how Joshua’s doing. I’m a little shook up because I got in the fender bender. And he says, are you okay? Yeah, I’m fine, but man, you know, I think the car is totaled.
And because he’s a good friend, he puts his arm around you and he says, I’m glad you’re okay. But, you know, this really doesn’t matter in the grand scheme of things. Okay? He— now, that’s not going to take away and fix the car, okay? That’s not going to immediately make you emotionally sanguine.
You’re not going to immediately, you know, go into elation and happiness. But you can recognize what he’s trying to do. And you can appreciate what he’s trying to do. You know what, Joshua? In a year’s time, you’re going to look back at this, and although this stinks, there are bigger things in life.
Why is that sort of very common phrase and kind of assurance meaningful to us? It’s because of this: we care about the grand scheme of things. The only way that that kind of assurance makes any kind of sense is if the human heart really does care about things mattering in the grand scheme of things. It’s not enough for us just to be occupied with things mattering to me. The human heart wants more, and we cannot live, even through a fender bender, without bumping up to our care and our concern of the gross cosmic scheme of things, of things mattering in some sense above the sun.
We don’t want to work for nothing, but we want it to mean something beyond us, something beyond the sun. All of us need to hear this. If you’re an unbeliever and listening to these words, you need to listen to the teacher who is doing this experiment, your work is not enough. But believers, we are not off the hook either. Because even as a believer and a follower of Christ, so many of us, including me, demand from work what only someone above the sun can give.
And this is part of my story, part of why I picked this particular text. Work looms quite large in the Smith family. I grew up on a small farm in Kentucky. It’s been in our family about 5 generations, and just for the comings and goings and the operation of the farm, it requires a lot of work. You’ve got to till the ground, you’ve got to harvest the crops, and I noticed as I was going up through middle school how when I would see my cousin— I I come from a huge family, see my cousins and see my aunts and uncles, that we would almost have a bragging fest of how much work we’ve done in the past year.
Oh, you planted that many crops? Let me tell you how many I planted. I was working 25 hours a day! Because work is seen as the highest virtue. And you know what?
I hated it. I hated it. As a middle schooler, I felt like, why are none of my friends— I didn’t have any friends who were also sons of farmers. And I felt like I was missing out on life. On Saturday, which was always a big farming day, I would have to get up, I would have to do some manual labor, and my friends got to sleep in or go and do— In reality, my parents gave me every opportunity that my peers had, but that’s how it felt like.
That’s what it felt like to a young middle school boy. And then something changed. In high school, I got on the Smith bandwagon. I started to like it. I started to like the accolades and the recognition that came from hard work, not only in farming, but also in other areas of life, in academics, and even working on myself, being a good person, having good character, being chivalrous to my girlfriend, respecting my elders, and so on.
And inasmuch as I had vague kind of thoughts about God, I would think, well, look how hard I am working. He has to accept me. He has to let me in. I was working from accept— for acceptance from others, but also even from God. And can I be honest with you?
Work still commands this over me. It’s still a great temptation, even working and preparing this very sermon. And so, I need to hear the words of Ecclesiastes, work is good, but it is not God. Work is good, and we’re going to see a gift, but it is not your God. If I continue to think that my work, even the work of preaching, is going to satisfy my heart, I will be chasing after the wind just like the teacher.
So that’s the teacher’s first point. Work in itself is not big enough. Work as work is not big enough. But then he gives us another way to view work. And I think this is going to resonate with some of you because for some of you, you’re going to think, okay, you know what?
Mattering just to me, that’s kind of selfish and self-centered. Self-centered, but that’s not why I work. I work to serve others. I’m building something that I want to give to my family. I want to give back to the community or make the world a better place.
It doesn’t really have to factor into above the sun or some eternal consequence, but it’s enough for me to be working for something and towards something that I can give to someone who comes after me. And the teacher considers this view of work as well. We can call this, and this is your second point, work as legacy. Work as legacy. Is this enough?
Is work as legacy enough? Let’s read again starting in verse 18, chapter 2, verse 18. He says this, I hated all things I had toiled for under the sun. Because I must leave them to one who comes after me. And who knows whether he will be a wise man or a fool?
Yet he will have control over all the work into which I have poured my effort and skill under the sun. This too is meaningless. So my heart began to despair over all my toil— toilsome labor under the sun.
All monuments of work will be superseded.
All artifacts may even be discarded. What pains the teacher is that even when we do good things— he’s not critiquing bad work. He’s not critiquing evil work. He has in his sights good, even altruistic work, and he says it’s not enough. It will either be discarded, defamed, or destroyed.
And so, we’re at a loss. He’s looked at work, something that commands so much of our affections and heart’s longings here in our culture today, and he has said it is not big enough. Work in itself and work as legacy are not going to do it. And then, he comes to our 3rd and final point, to consider work as a gift.
And in this section, and it’s a bit complex, you’re going to have to follow me here, he both gives us a glimmer, a flicker of light to the answer of how we’re going to find meaning, but that flame is blown out in an instant. And we’re going to have to hold on to that fire, okay? Let’s go hunting for that fire as we go back in. Look at verse 24. We’re in chapter 2, verse 24.
This is the end of his reflection. He says, a man can do nothing better than to eat and drink and find satisfaction in his work. This too, I see, is from the hand of God, for without him who can eat or find enjoyment? To the man who pleases him, God gives wisdom, knowledge, and happiness, but to the sinner he gives the task of gathering and storing up wealth to hand it over to the one who pleases God. This too is meaningless, a chasing after the wind.
There’s a puzzle here in these 3 verses. He’s just spent 2 and a half chapters, and we didn’t read all of it obviously, but he spent 2 and a half chapters on a big down note, okay, in despair. All is meaningless. That’s what was read the first 3 3 verses of chapter 1. Vanity of vanity, all is meaningless.
This is the first glimmer of positivity that we see in the book. Notice also in these 3 verses that the phrase under the sun is not mentioned. Something has happened. Something has entered. We are in a different vantage point, and that vantage point is viewing work as a gift.
As a gift. You can only find meaning in work, indeed meaning in your life, if you see it as a gift of God. In considering gift and the giver that gives this gift, the teacher has opened himself up and us as readers above the sun. To above the sun. And it is above the sun that his heart and our heart, that’s what they really want.
God gives work that echoes in eternity. You matter. Your work matters. If we view work under the sun, the teacher is telling us it destroys meaning in work and in life. But if we view and receive work as a gift given from God above the sun, then we find meaning in work and in life.
Get 2 for 1 there. So, how do we get this gift? We’re not out of the woods yet. The preacher says, really, it’s a toss-up. The reason why he ends on such a down note that he continues to conclude that everything is meaningless is because to him, to the teacher, it’s a toss-up of who gets to receive work as a gift and who doesn’t.
He doesn’t know. It looks like it just is haphazard and random, those who receive work as a gift and those who do not. You can find meaning in work. It’s as if he’s saying, if you please God, but how or whether you get to do that? I don’t really know.
But we know something that the preacher does not.
We know something that the teacher could only imagine. Look what he says again. I’m in verse 24, a man can do nothing better than to eat and drink and find satisfaction in his work. This too I see is from the hand of for without him who can eat or find enjoyment? Verse 26, underline this, highlight this, to him, to the man who pleases him, God gives wisdom.
Who is it who pleases God?
Many centuries after this teacher is giving and reflecting, another teacher with 3 students comes along doing something very similar to what this teacher is doing. This teacher takes his 3 students up on a mountain. These students are hanging on every word that this teacher is saying, and this teacher is silent. All of a sudden, something miraculous happens. This teacher is engulfed in a cloud that’s brilliant and blinding, and they hear a voice, not of their teacher, but of God.
And God says this, this is my Son in whom I am well pleased. Pleased. Listen to Him.
Who is the one who pleases God? Not me, not the teacher, not you. Jesus.
Jesus is the one who pleases God. Jesus is the one that the teacher only hinted at but did not know. The biggest work that you need is a work that you cannot do. To please God. And pleasing God unlocks everything for the teacher.
He just does not know how to obtain it. He knew the condition for finding meaning in life, meaning in work. He did not know how to get it. But we do. We do, and this is the gospel.
The problem of meaning in work is bigger than meaning in work. Do you hear that? The problem of of the loss of meaning in work is bigger than the loss of meaning in work. The problem of meaning in work is a symptom of a much, much bigger problem, really the problem, the problem of our own sin. We are not pleasing to God because of our sin.
We are not righteous. We break our vows. We treat other— we treat our work as little gods. We indulge in lust, and gossip, and I could go on, but Jesus— Jesus completely pleases God. He is perfect.
He is completely righteous. Yet, He is condemned as a criminal and takes on the punishment as if He sinned. Why? So that by trusting in Him, you may now please God. For those in Christ, God looks at you And He does not see your idolatry, the way that you treat work as a god or that you dismiss it as if it’s not a gift, your broken vows, your secret sins, but the pleasant perfection of Jesus in whom I am well pleased.
And notice that this doesn’t just transform your spiritual life, it transforms your work. You don’t discard it. It’s not discarded but ennobled. It’s not idolatrous but seen as a gift. In a phrase, we’re now able to see above the sun and how our work fits into it.
Remember me working for God? Remember how I was working to be a good person? And by all human accounts, I was pretty good at it. But a conversation when I was 17, a conversation with, of all people, a Christian choir teacher at my public high school, begins asking me about my life. And she hears, wow, Joshua is racking up this list of being righteous.
And she starts to go and talk to me about the true gospel of the Lord Jesus Christ that we just heard, and saying, your best efforts are filthy rags before a holy and just God. You cannot work enough. And on the presentation of that, seeing my desperate need for righteousness that I did not have, I flung myself on Jesus at the age of 17. And He has ever since been changing my life, and He can change yours too. Will you seek Him and accept Him by faith, not only for your work but for your entire life?
That’s the only way you’re going to find meaning in either of them. Come to the One who has completed this ultimate work for you. Let us pray.
Lord Jesus, forgive us when we view things of this world, our work, or really anything else as if they are the Creator God. We all admit that this is part of our human tendency. It’s part of why we’re fallen, and so we look to You to be the Redeemer. We fling ourself on You, God, if we’re an unbeliever for the first time, if a believer again and again, day by day, because we all need the gospel. We all need to be reminded.
Would You be gentle with us? Will You show us the finished work of Christ and how that is the answer to all of our meaning? It’s in His name we pray, amen.

