Good News, Bad News, Now What?

What do you do when you know you’ve messed up? In Israel’s case, what do you do when you know you’ve messed up for about 1000 years? At least equally important, what does God do? Will He be gracious? Or will He levy justice? This week in Nehemiah, we’ll see how Israel’s leaders talked about their past, what they hoped for their future, and how God’s response informs our lives today.


Sermon Transcript

Before we look at our text, for today, I’d like to just take a moment and pray for our nation. There’s been a recent increase in violence, especially against our citizens of Asian descent, and that is so troubling and disheartening. We, we want to affirm the dignity and worth of every single person and speak against violence whenever it happens. And we know violence in some ways is always happening.

But there seems to be an increase against this particular group. And so we just, we just, we just want to pray for, for peace and unity, pray against hate in our country. So pray with me for a moment, will you? Father, we thank you for every human being on the planet. We pray that our hearts would be to love our neighbor As you instruct us to, Lord, we pray for, for, for our friends and family and countrymen of, of Asian descent in this, in this country, Lord, that you would, you would protect them, that they wouldn’t have fear, that, that us as a general community can make, can make our, our friends and loved ones who fear make them feel safe Lord, we pray against violence, we pray against hate, and we pray that your gospel would spread to the whole country and to the whole world to transform us more into your image.

We pray all those things in Jesus’ name. Amen. Well, hey, if you haven’t been tracking along with our online services for the past couple of months, Let me catch you up. We’ve been studying an ancient text which recorded a rebuilding effort of a town that had been destroyed. And it might sound as if that event would have nothing to do with our lives today, but we’ve actually seen a good bit of overlap between their circumstances of regathering as a people and our circumstances.

They, they needed to relaunch their town And we have needed to relaunch our world, so to speak, you know, after not meeting in person for so long. So, a little historical recap. The city of Jerusalem had been utterly destroyed, but eventually people started to come back to the land. And when they did, they didn’t— not everybody came back all at once. They returned to Jerusalem in groups.

The first group rebuilt the temple so they could worship. The second group worked basically to align the people with what God wanted, to align the people with God’s desires. And then the third group, which is the group that we have been studying, they rebuilt the walls around Jerusalem, which would help protect the city. And the first thing they did after they got the walls up, this is what Steve talked about 2 weeks ago, they read God’s law for hours and hours, day after day. They just read what, what they had of the Bible at that point.

They read it to the whole community for days. So just a small commentary for us as we are relaunching as a society. And all of us, this is what we’re doing, right? We’re, we’re trying to figure out what is it that we should add back into our lives And what is it that’s okay if we just never pick that up again, right? So, some of us at this time we’re thinking, wow, I really want to prioritize travel because I never want to miss another opportunity to travel in case something gets shut down again.

Others of us might think, you know what, I don’t really miss going out to eat, for example, so maybe when I have the opportunity to do that again I just won’t start doing that again. Like, we’re all sorting out So, we are all sorting out what we should add into our lives and what we shouldn’t. So, it is worth noting the importance these ancient people placed on worship and saturating themselves with the Word of God, with the Bible. It is what we should do. If all of us are relaunching our lives, so what do we put at the center when we relaunch.

Read the Bible, pray, go to church, right? Read the Bible, pray, go to church. Put that at the center. So, these ancient people, they have read the Bible out loud for days. What happens next?

They have rebuilt the temple, they have rebuilt the walls, and they have read the Bible out loud for a week. Now what? That is what we are talking about today. What happens next is that the people who gathered to hear God’s word realize how unfaithful their nation has been to God. They are confronted with their past, and their past is unfortunately full of sin.

They are carrying a lot of shame as a nation, a lot of regret. They have a long history of disobedience to God. So, the leaders, when they realize this, they start praying and they own up to everything they have done as a nation for the past 1,000 years. That is what Nehemiah chapter 9 is. It is a long prayer of owning their past.

So, as we look at this prayer from so long ago and we apply their situation to our lives, we will see the good news, the bad news, and now what? The good news for us, the bad news for us, and now what? So, first, the good news. Verse 17, God is gracious and merciful, slow to anger, abounding in steadfast love, ready to forgive. God is gracious and merciful, slow to anger, abounding in steadfast love, ready to forgive.

Have you ever wondered if you have strayed too far from God? You’ve been too bad for too long and now God won’t take you back. Is that ever a concern of yours? You know, I’ve reached the limit. God forgave me before but I continued in disobedience so he’s surely done with me now.

Have you ever been there?

These Israelite leaders in this text, they summarize the whole history of Israel and it is not flattering. Israel is not faithful to her God. Different commentators count it differently, but there are about 6 repetitions of Israel’s disobedience and God’s response. Verses 9 through 15, God rescues Israel out of Egyptian slavery, but verses 16 and 17, Israel responds with ungratefulness and wants to return to slavery. Yet God didn’t forsake them.

Then verse 18 to 25, the Israelites actually make a golden calf and worship it instead of worshiping the real God who brought them out of slavery. Yet even then, God provides food and water in the midst of the desert. He brings them into a fertile land and settles them there. But verse 26, the Israelites were unfaithful again, didn’t listen to God. They even killed his prophets, right?

But then verse 27, God gave them into the hand of their enemies who made them suffer. But when they suffered, they cried out to God, and according to God’s great mercies, he saved them from the hands of their enemies. Verse 28, after they had rest from their enemies. They did evil again, so God handed them over to their enemies again. Yet when they turned and cried to God, he delivered them again according to his mercies.

Back and forth, back and forth for 1,000 years. Rebel against God, receive forgiveness, rebel against God, suffer under just punishment for the rebellion, cry out receive forgiveness and restoration, and then rebel against God again for 1,000 years.

Can you relate to this story?

Run from God, crash and burn, be restored, run from God over and over and over again. Does that sound familiar?

It’s more than Israel’s story. It’s the human story. We resist what God wants for us. We rebel against him. That’s, that’s us back to our earliest ancestors.

Right. And to Israel’s credit, they don’t hide from that history or try to cover it up or try to excuse it. They openly admit, like, hey, we aren’t the heroes of this story. In the small recap of the saga of Israel, they make their own nation look pretty pathetic and they exalt God as Savior and Hero. One of the oddities about Israelite history compared to other ancient nations is how disparaging Israelites are of themselves.

You read other historical records of empires and what does the historian say? You know, the historian is getting paid by the king, so he better say something pretty nice, and he does. The historian says, we are amazing, right? We defeated all our enemies. Our kings are enshrined in eternal glory.

That is basically how other nations view themselves. You don’t, for instance, find Rome writing about how terrible Rome was. You don’t find the Tang Dynasty writing about how terrible the Tang Dynasty was. Right now, when one empire defeats another one, the victorious empire will talk trash about the loser, of course. Right.

And empires will at some point record some military losses. Right. So other nations are not always 100% favorable about themselves. But Israel is unique. Israel constantly records how terrible they are.

And they record victories too, that’s true, but they spend much more time, very uniquely to them, they spend more time on their failures. There’s something remarkable about that. They knew who the hero was. They they fully admitted they had only gotten to where they were by sheer grace. If God were not forgiving, abounding in mercy, full of compassion, they would be nowhere.

God had restored them, provided for them, pardoned them over and over and over again. His patience is immeasurable. You read these paragraphs and you kind of gotta wonder, like, God, why didn’t— why didn’t you just bail on these people? Why did you give them another chance again? You’re like, God, I don’t know if I kind of feel awkward telling you this, but you might be getting taken advantage of here.

Why would you do that? Because God is gracious and merciful, slow to anger. Abounding in steadfast love, ready to forgive. So question for us, how, how could we read this account of Israel’s millennia of failure and yet still sometimes believe that there’s no hope for us? You know, God won’t forgive us.

We’ve strayed too far. We have too many secrets, too many skeletons. God saw what I did in the dark. There’s no way he wants to have anything to do with me.

Don’t ever think that.

Your sin is not bigger than God’s mercy. We should look at Israel and be encouraged. God is gracious and merciful, slow to anger, abounding in steadfast love, ready to forgive. Okay, that’s the good news. You’ve never gone too far.

Forgiveness is always available. That’s the good news. Now, the bad news, we don’t deserve mercy.

We don’t deserve it. These leaders, verse 33, say, God has been righteous in all the difficulties that have come upon the Israelites. Sending them into captivity, delivering them into the hand of their enemies. These, these leaders understand God is the one who gave them over to their enemies. You know, they didn’t randomly fall into the hand of their enemies.

Verse 27, verse 30. God was not passive in the hardships that they faced. God set the stage for the hardships. God says, I’m going to hand you over to these people, and these people will make you suffer. And the leaders in response tell God, it was right for you to hand us over.

They aren’t whining about it. They aren’t playing the victim. They say, we deserve to be exiled, and now even though we’ve come back from exile, we don’t deserve to be free from the oppression we are still under. Israel at the time this was written is still ruled by Persia. They are home— the Israelites are living in Jerusalem— but whatever the land produces isn’t really theirs.

It belongs to the Persian king, right? So these leaders say like, we are, we are slaves in our own home, verse 36 to 37. And they tell God it is righteous of God to lay this burden on them. So in other words, they’re saying, God, you haven’t done anything wrong by squashing us we deserve to be squashed. So, for us, if for some reason we believe that we could take advantage of God’s mercy and forgiveness, if we believe we can just act however we want and God will let it slide, our second bullet point for today corrects our error.

God is not going to be mocked. And if you grew up Catholic, you might have the idea you can sin however much you want as long as you just go to confession and talk about it, right? If you grew up Protestant, we have the same idea except we just take the priest out of it and we think, it’s okay if I do this because I can just ask for forgiveness later.

God will not be taken advantage of like that. This prayer in Nehemiah 9 protects us from falling into 2 very big but very opposite errors. First error we already talked about: Nehemiah 9 protects us from believing that our sin is bigger than God’s forgiveness, right? That’s not true. God’s forgiveness is always bigger than our sin.

Forgiveness is always available. But the second error, equally as great, Nehemiah 9 protects us from believing that we can presume upon grace and that God is indifferent to how we live. Both of those are wrong. Thinking God won’t forgive us is wrong. Thinking that it doesn’t matter how we live because God will always forgive us Also wrong.

Both wrong. This is important because sometimes focusing on God’s forgiveness can make us lose sight of the fact that God is serious about holiness. We can live as if our personal righteousness is inconsequential, right? We can forget that God is a judge and a good one. He doesn’t let guilty people off the hook, nor should He, and we are guilty people.

So, when you picture yourself standing before God and giving an account of your life, Does it ever cause you to tremble?

It should, because God is a judge and a good one. He won’t let guilty people off the hook.

Now, if you’ve been paying attention, you should be wondering, how do these things play together, right? We just said God was abounding in love, full of mercy, ready to forgive, and now we’re saying he’s a good judge that won’t let people off the hook. You should be kind of wondering, well, which one is it? Right? This prayer here in Nehemiah 9 creates a tension which it doesn’t resolve.

It lists all of Israel’s sins, it calls God righteous, and at the same time it documents God’s history of patient mercy. All right, verse 32, they ask for relief of their hardship, but they also say, verse 33, we deserve the hardship. It is like they are asking, God, I mean, we know that You are righteous for sure, but maybe, here is an idea, just want to throw this out there, God, have You ever thought about not being righteous? How about that? Like, we have done the crime, we admit that freely, but could You release us from serving the time.

I mean, we deserve to serve the time, no question, we deserve punishment, amen, and any good judge would make us serve the time, and you are a good judge. You don’t let anyone off the hook because you’re righteous, but here’s an idea, God, could you maybe just not be a good judge for a minute? Could you let us off the hook? There is tension. Is God going to be holy and righteous, or is he going to be merciful and compassionate?

If God really held people accountable for what they had done, then he would not be merciful and compassionate. And if he released the guilty from the punishment they deserve, if he showed mercy, which is what they’re asking for, then he wouldn’t be holy and righteous. So, what’s going to happen? Which is He going to be?

That tension runs all the way through the Old Testament. God claims to be absolute in His holiness, and yet He fudges on that holiness and acts compassionately all the time. So, what’s that about, and how can that be resolved? Now, one possible resolution to that tension is maybe the guilty people could earn back their good standing through improved performance. This is what we do with our employees, right?

Your sales numbers are down, your boss says, we have standards here, you know, we cannot relax those standards for anyone, but if you get your act together, if you turn it around next quarter, if you exceed expectations, we will let you stay. You are going to earn it back. That is what happens at work, right? And we try sometimes to do this with God, don’t we? We have messed up, but now we want His help to get us out of a jam, so we pledge our future faithfulness.

We say, I will always go to church. I will help people. I won’t be mean to that annoying guy anymore. Like, we try earn it back. That’s logical.

That’s actually what these Israelite leaders do in the next chapter, which Steve will cover next week. They say, they say, we’ll be good from now on, we promise. Like, please forgive us, we won’t mess up anymore, God. That’s Nehemiah chapter 10, which if it weren’t so tragic, it would be hilarious, right? They’ve just recounted the last thousand years of Israel’s history, all of which was dismal unfaithfulness.

Then the next words out of their mouth, right?

But we’re gonna be different from now on, right? Never mind that dozens of generations before us all failed. Let’s just ignore that because unlike them, we are going to have our act together.

Good luck, Israel. And spoiler alert, Israel’s history after this declaration isn’t a lot different than Israel’s history before this declaration. They don’t make up for past failures. They don’t improve their performance. So the possibility that this tension between God’s righteousness and God’s compassion might be resolved by improving our performance doesn’t actually work in the real world.

Israel continues its disobedience just like we continue our disobedience. Even if you aren’t a Christian and you just kind of believe in some kind of karma where, you know, what goes around comes around and somehow the universe will repay you for the right or the wrong that you have done, If that’s what you believe, how are you doing?

You ever get very far into the positive side of that ledger, or do you constantly find that there’s always more and more and more that you need to be making up for?

We can’t work our way out of it, can we? If we are honestly evaluating ourselves, we know we deserve more penalty, yet at the same time we want mercy and compassion. So, what is God going to do about it? Will He grant compassion and lose His righteousness, or will He enforce His righteousness and forsake His compassion?

The end. Amen. Let’s pray and we will cut to the band. See you next week.

It would be terrible to end right there, wouldn’t it? But that’s how the Old Testament ends. It doesn’t answer that question. It predicts the answer to that question all over the place, but it doesn’t fulfill it. The Old Testament ends with a big now what?

What is the resolution to that tension?

Jesus.

Jesus is now what? Jesus is the resolution to that tension. The tension between God’s righteousness and God’s compassion is resolved when Jesus goes to the cross. On the cross, God’s compassion and God’s justice meet. God maintains his righteousness by pouring out the full penalty that sin deserves onto Jesus.

Jesus is cursed, Galatians 3:13. Jesus is forsaken, Matthew 27:46. So God is still righteous. He doesn’t let anything go unpunished. Jesus is punished for sin, for our sin.

But at the same time, God is compassionate because the people who committed the crime, namely us, we are freed from the punishment that we deserve. The guilty are not cursed. The guilty are not forsaken. And instead innocent Jesus stands in our place, right? The tension is resolved.

God is both merciful and at the same time righteously just. So with us and our sin, with our pasts, with our skeletons, we don’t fluff them off as no big deal. Right? They, they are such a big deal Jesus had to die in order to clear our record before God. The cross teaches us how big a deal sin is, but at the same time, the cross teaches us that God’s compassion is even bigger than our sin.

There is no skeleton from our past so big that the cross can’t overcome it. If Jesus were willing to endure crucifixion to clear your record, there is nothing on your record that still needs to be cleared. The cross has spoken. You are forgiven. And you are forgiven not because you have tried to make up for it, Rather, you are forgiven through trusting what Jesus did on your behalf.

You don’t clear your record. Jesus cleared it for you so that you may receive God’s mercy and compassion. Let’s pray.

Father, we are so grateful that you are both a merciful and just, that you both will not stand for wrongdoing because you are a good judge, and at the same time you are compassionate and forgive us. Lord, we thank you most of all that, that there is no tension between those two because of what Jesus did on our behalf, that you maintain your righteousness and you maintain your compassion through Jesus’ sacrifice, Lord, taking what we deserve so that we may receive what we do not deserve, namely forgiveness from you. Lord, we pray that we would trust in Jesus to clear our record before you, that we may receive forgiveness, restoration, and to relationship with you. We pray all those things in Jesus’ name. Amen.