The Paralytic, the Tax Collector, and the Rabbi

Many of us are naturally curious about the type of people who will be welcomed by God, and many of us probably have our own assumptions regarding who might be “in” and who might be “out.” The people in the first century weren’t any different. They, like us, drew circles of inclusion and exclusion, but what we will see this week is that Jesus completely turned their assumptions on their heads. To the surprise of everyone, Jesus included even the most unlikely of characters into His Kingdom.


Sermon Transcript

The scripture reading today is taken from Mark chapter 2, verse 1 to 17.

And it is from the English Standard Version, ESV.

And when he returned to Capernaum after some days, it was reported that he was at home, and many were gathered together so that there was no room, not even at the door. Door, and he was preaching the word to them. And they came bringing to him a paralytic carried by 4 men. And when they could not get near him because of the crowd, they removed the roof above him, and when they had made an opening, they let down the bed on which the paralytic lay.

And when Jesus saw their faith, he said to the paralytic, Son, your sins are forgiven. Now some of the scribes were sitting there questioning in their hearts, why does this man speak like that? He is blaspheming. Who can forgive sins but God alone? And immediately Jesus, perceiving in his spirit Spirit that they thus questioned within themselves and said to them, why do you question these things in your hearts?

Which is easier, to say to the paralytic, your sins are forgiven, or to say, rise, take up your bed, and walk? But that you may know that the Son of Man has authority on earth to forgive sins, he said to the paralytic, I say to you, rise, pick up your bed, and go home. And he rose and immediately picked up his bed and went out before them all, so that they were all amazed and glorified God, saying, we never saw anything like this.

He went out again beside the sea, and all the crowd was coming to him and he was teaching them. And as he passed by, he saw Levi the son of Alphaeus sitting at the tax booth, and he said to him, Follow me. And he rose and followed him.

And as he reclined at table in his house, many tax collectors and sinners were reclining with Jesus and his disciples. For there were many who followed him. And the scribes of the Pharisees, when they saw that he was eating with sinners and tax collectors, said to his disciples, why does he eat with tax collectors and sinners? And when Jesus heard it, he said to them, those who are well have no need of a physician, but those who are sick. I came not to call the righteous, but sinners.

May the Lord bless the reading of his holy word.

Thanks, John.

There is, uh, perhaps not a more important question than who does God include and who does God exclude?

Different religions, different cultures have answered that question different ways. In Hindu, it’s officially abolished now, but the caste system was meant to answer that question. If you were a pariah in the low caste, it meant you were excluded. You’d messed up somehow and your current position in the world was partially a punishment for your past sins. So of course the rest of society couldn’t help you or give you any kind of rights because that would interfere with the justice the universe was delivering to you in the position that you’re in.

Islam has had its answers for who is included and who is excluded, and that answer has changed throughout history and it varies It varies depending on what sect of Islam you’re talking about, but they all have an answer for who is in and who isn’t. In ancient Judaism, they largely thought Israel was included because God had chosen them and given them the law, and these pagan Gentile sinners, well, they were excluded. And, of course, not everybody in ancient Judaism thought that, and there’s Old Testament accounts all over the place like the book of Jonah that show God’s love for all peoples, but it was certainly a prevalent idea that Israel was in and everyone else was out. Jonah himself wanted it to be that way, which is why God was giving him a hard time. And then Jesus arrives and He has His own standard for who is included by God, and it shocked everyone.

In our text today, we see Jesus interact with 3 different people. And as Jesus progresses from one person to the next, his teaching on who God includes becomes more and more radical, and it gets him in more and more trouble. Specifically, we see Jesus interact with a paralytic, a tax collector, and the rabbis. Paralytic, the tax collector, collector and a rabbi. So first, the paralytic.

In the 1st century, many people, including Israelites, believed that if someone had a physical illness or a chronic condition, it meant that person had sinned somehow, was on the outs with God. And on the opposite side, of course, physical health must mean that the person had favor with So, for example, we see in John 9, the disciples ask Jesus about a man who was born blind. You might remember this story. And they ask Jesus, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind? Because in their mind, it had to be one of them.

Somebody must have done something along the line for this guy to have this condition. And Jesus corrects them and says, neither. But it’s the same— you see the same thing in Job’s friends in the book of Job. Job’s friends tell Job, the only reason you have these problems is because you have sinned. God is not unjust, Job, so if you had been doing the right thing, none of this would have happened to you.

They tell Job, hey, if you repent and you get your life right, you’ll be healthy again. Chapter after chapter, Job’s friends tell him that. And we would respond to Job’s friends or Jesus’ disciples about the man who was born blind, we would tell them, like, how could you tell someone with a chronic condition that it was their fault? That’s the last thing that you would want to tell someone who is suffering from some sort of affliction. We would scold them if they were here.

But actually, we aren’t so much different in some of our beliefs today. When we talk about— when people When people, for instance, talk about God giving them favor, what they mean by favor is having more comfort, probably health and wealth, but just things going well in our lives. There’s the hashtag blessed, right? So people redo their kitchen and then they post a picture, hashtag blessed, sitting on the beach, hashtag blessed, got a promotion, hashtag blessed, I got a good bill of health, I was cured, #blessed. And here’s a picture, I’m going to post it, of me receiving favor from God.

So, comfort equals favor, which I hope you do have a lot of comfort. But there is an underlying insinuation in that messaging that if you don’t have the kitchen, the vacation, the promotion, the cure, you therefore aren’t blessed. You therefore don’t have favor with God, or at least you don’t have as much favor as others do because no one is posting pictures of uncomfortable situations with the hashtag blessed. I’ve never seen anyone post, had to work extra hours this week, hashtag blessed. Been fighting a headache all day, right?

Hashtag blessed. My car was totaled, hashtag blessed. We don’t say those things. Things, which means in our hearts, many of us aren’t that different from the ancient Israelites who equated comfort to blessing or favor from God. If we have comfort, we’re in with him, we have his favor.

If we don’t have comfort, we must be out with him, we’ve lost favor. And perhaps more revealing to what our hearts truly believe is when we look at other people who have more comfort than us and we say, what did they do to deserve that? Or why is God giving that to them and not to me? Haven’t I been just as good enough, right enough, long enough as they have to earn that favor? Don’t I deserve it as much as they do?

See, we’re not that different from people in the first They had an equation. If I’m good, I’ll be in with God and He’ll bless me, that equals comfort. That equation is still in our hearts somewhere. They were more explicit about it than we are, but we have the same underlying belief. And they went ahead and took it to its logical conclusion because they outright said anyone without comfort, prosperity, health must be cursed by God.

They just worked the equation backward. If someone was sick, they would say out loud to the person, like Job’s friends, oh, you must have lost God’s favor. We don’t take it that far, but it is the logical conclusion because if comfort equals favor, what does discomfort equal?

They would answer that question. They had answered that question. It was up and running in their minds. Chronic illness meant you had been cursed. Cursed by God.

So in our text, here comes a paralytic falling from the ceiling. Pretty cool that this guy’s friends were willing to tear off a roof and design some kind of rope system to get him to Jesus. That’s pretty cool. It should make us ask, what are we willing to do to get our friends to Jesus? But that’s not where we’re going today.

Here comes a paralytic descending from the right in the middle of Jesus teaching about something. We don’t know what Jesus was in the middle of teaching, which totally makes sense because if our roof tore open right now and someone was lowered on a stretcher to the middle of the room, none of us would remember anything that was said this morning. The only thing we would remember was the giant distraction that came from the ceiling. But Jesus, of course, unfazed, leans into that distraction, and He not only helps the guy who’s being lowered, which He’ll do in a second, but He helps everyone else there as well because everyone in the room or most everyone in the room is assuming the only reason this guy is a paralytic is because he has lost favor with God, and they’re wrong. Physical illness does not mean you have lost favor with God.

Health does not mean you have favor with God. There’s a different indicator for whether or not you have favor, which we’ll see later. But everyone thinks sickness means you’ve lost favor. So, Jesus gets to work overturning everyone’s assumptions. He tells the paralytic, your sins are forgiven.

God includes you. Your illness does not mean that you have lost favor with God. In fact, the debt between you and God is totally clear. You don’t owe anything anymore. I have forgiven you.

Now, we’re not told what the paralytic thought about that. He might have thought, who cares about my sins? Like, that’s not why my friends brought me here. I just want to walk again. I mean, thanks for the forgiveness, but hello, I’m still a paralytic dangling from the roof.

You gonna do anything about that? Maybe that is what he thought. I don’t know. Or maybe, more likely given the culture around him, maybe he was carrying a lot of self-blame. Beating himself up, believing he had been cast out from God for something that he had done.

Did you know people still ask that today? People with terminal illnesses or chronic conditions, they sometimes ask, is this my fault? Am I being punished for something? Is God mad at me? Even today, we can sometimes carry self-blame when we have an illness.

And praise God, today we probably all have voices around us, friends who would tell us, of course it’s not your fault. Don’t beat yourself up. This could happen to anyone. Praise God we have that probably today. But in the first century, this guy would have had the opposite voices around him.

The paralytic would have heard, it is your fault. You are disabled because of you, just like Job’s friends told him. And it’s hard to overcome that psychologically. It’s hard to believe illnesses are not curses even now when everyone around us would be telling us, don’t blame yourself. It’s hard enough then.

Because we still have the voice in our head. But it’s basically impossible to believe illnesses aren’t curses when everyone around you is reinforcing the voice of self-blame in your head.

And that’s what this guy had dealt with for however long he’d been afflicted.

And then Jesus releases him from that. Jesus says, your sins are forgiven. You have favor from God. God. God has not cast you out.

You are as in with him as you are going to get.

Notice Jesus declares forgiveness for the paralytic before, before he’s healed, before anyone knows that he’s going to be healed. So the forgiveness stands on its own. It is unrelated to his illness. Jesus forgives the guy free and clear, and yet he’s still a paralytic. And then people start murmuring about Jesus, not about the guy.

People aren’t talking about the guy because something much more dramatic than the roof being torn off and someone descending from above has now occurred. Jesus claimed he had the ability to forgive sins, something they understood God alone could do. Talk more about that in a second. But now the most interesting thing in the room is Jesus and who he thinks he is. And therefore, in order to prove who he is, Jesus heals the guy.

Jesus says, so that everyone here will know I have the authority to forgive sins, take up your mat and walk. Jesus does not say, so that everyone here will know that this guy has favor with God, take up your sin or take up your mat and walk, right? The healing had everything to do with Jesus’ identity. It had nothing to do with whether the guy was favored or not.

Now, about Jesus claiming to be God, we’ll take a small side quest here to the main plotline of our message and then we’ll come back. As we’ve said, in Jewish understanding, God alone could forgive sins. So, when Jesus announced this man’s sins were forgiven, the crowd correctly accused Jesus of blasphemy. By the way, it’s pretty common sense that only God could forgive sins because just think, who has the authority to forgive any type of debt? Who can do that?

It’s only the one who is owed. That’s it. You know, if there were a loan, it would be the creditor, right? So, let’s say you have an auto loan with Ford and you still own loan, you still owe $20K. Who could release you from that debt?

Ford. Like, that’s it. I can’t release you from that debt. You owe them, not me. Your friend can’t release you.

Your mom can’t release you. None of us can say, you’re forgiven from your auto loan. We can’t. We have no authority to say that because the debt isn’t against us. We aren’t the one that you owe.

So, we can’t forgive you. Only the one you owe can forgive you. That makes sense. So, when Jesus says, your sins are forgiven, the people rightly heard, rightly understood Jesus was saying, I am the one that you owe for your sins. I am the one that you offend when you sin, and therefore, I have the authority to release you from your guilt.

If Jesus isn’t correct, for sure he is committing blasphemy, for sure. But not only does Jesus say it, he doubles down on it because after the religious leaders accuse him of blasphemy, they ask, who can forgive sin but God alone? And Jesus does not make a case that someone besides God could have the authority to forgive sin. Like, this would have been the moment to clear everything up if he were not claiming to be God, because he could have explained, like, yes, I, I have the authority to forgive sins. I understand the confusion, but no, uh, I’m not claiming to be God.

And then he could have offered some kind of reason that he had the authority to forgive sins without being God. It would have been the perfect opportunity for that lesson if it existed, but He didn’t do that. They ask, who can forgive sins but God alone? And Jesus says, I can.

I decide who is included with God, and I am including the paralytic. Side quest over. So, summary of our first point, Jesus flips everyone’s understanding of the world and says, the paralytic is favored by God. The paralytic is included. Next interaction, the tax collector.

Obviously, even today, we don’t love tax collectors. It must be a giant bummer at a party if you have to introduce yourself as an IRS agent, especially this time of year. But in the first century, for the Israelites, it was far worse. They were an occupied nation, so someone collecting taxes was working for the conquering government, which means Roman taxes were this ongoing reminder that they were not free. Their land was not theirs anymore.

And for the Israelites, the land was far more significant to them than it will ever be to us. Each plot of land had been in the same family for generations and generations as part of who they were, it’s like their identity. And on top of that, they believed God had promised them that land. So, when they were occupied by Rome, they’re asking questions like, has God forsaken us? How could this be happening?

And then for them to look over and see one of their own people standing on the side of Rome collecting taxes for the Roman government, it’s like, you are profiting off of our oppression? You are making money off the fact that we aren’t free and you’re one of us? There’s nothing more hurtful to an Israelite than to see another Israelite in that role. In their mind, it was the worst kind of betrayal. There was no one more reprehensible than a tax collector.

Like, notice, for instance, when there is a list of, we will say, unsavory people in Scripture, Tax collectors get their own category. Like here it says Jesus is with sinners and tax collectors. Like in other words, tax collectors were so bad the sinners didn’t want to be lumped in with them, right? Even the sinners would say like, okay, yes, I messed up, sure, but at least I’m not a tax collector. Like tax collectors were at the bottom of the morality scale.

It is uncomfortable to think of a modern equivalent.

Like, what is at the end of the line for us in terms of morality? If you were in prison, what would make you an outcast even in prison? What’s the thing you could have done that everyone else in prison would look at you and say, well, at least I didn’t do that? That’s tax collectors, and they had chosen that path. No one had forced them to be tax collectors.

They had made a deliberate choice to abandon their people, to spit in the face of God’s promises, and they did it publicly, right? It wasn’t a secret sin. It was ongoing. And then Jesus looks at one of these worst possible offenders named Levi, which is synonymous with Matthew, same name. Levi is Matthew, Matthew is Levi.

It’s who we believe wrote the book of Matthew, Jesus looks at him, a tax collector, and says, follow me. Jesus says, even tax collectors can be included with what I’m doing. But Jesus didn’t just include one tax collector. Here at the end of the passage, Jesus is eating with many tax collectors, plural. He was regularly with these people.

Eating with them. And eating, I mean, even today, eating with someone conveys a certain amount of relational connection or a desire to develop one. You invite someone over to dinner or you invite them out to lunch, and that’s more than just a meal. It’s a level of acceptance, right, even for us, and it was exponentially more for them. You certainly wouldn’t eat with someone who had robbed you.

Betrayed you, oppressed you, which is what tax collectors were doing. They had to— you probably know they had to collect a certain amount of taxes to send back to Rome, but then they could collect whatever else they wanted on top of that Roman requirement and keep it for themselves, which they did. They were robbers, exploiters, taking advantage of an already oppressed people. You would not have someone like that over to dinner. And the Israelite paradigm was eye for an eye and tooth for a tooth, right?

So, imagine what they would have wanted to do to a tax collector. They would have thought justice is stripping this tax collector down, taking back everything that had been taken from us, burning the tax collector’s house to the ground or moving into it ourselves, driving the guy to the middle of the desert and leaving him for dead. Like, justice is vengeance.

The only reason they didn’t stone tax collectors to death was because tax collectors were protected by the Roman government.

But then Jesus is eating with them.

And not only that, but Jesus had just equated Himself with God. So now, not only has Jesus said that those with chronic illnesses can be included with God, He adds that God could accept people who have done the unacceptable, even those who made a deliberate choice to oppose God, even those who made a public choice to oppose God over and over and over again, right? Levi is out there every day. He is in the middle of robbing people when Jesus says, you are with Me.

Jesus says the tax collector is in Do you know what that means for us?

Wherever you have been, however far down the morality scale you have chosen, deliberately chosen to jump, Jesus came for you.

No matter how public your sin has been, no matter how frequent it has been, no matter if you’re in the middle of it right now, no matter if you’ve been to jail and everyone else in prison looked on you with disgust, no matter how alone you feel, no matter how rejected you feel by everyone because of your sinful choices, Jesus came for you.

The indicator of whether you are in or out with God is not your moral goodness. Just like it was not your health. There’s something else that indicates whether you are in or out with God. Jesus will talk about it soon. But it is fantastic news for anyone who doesn’t feel good enough, who doesn’t feel worthy, for the tax collector type person, fantastic news that Jesus could include us even though we are morally messy, That’s great news for us, but it is maddening for anyone who feels better than the tax collector or more deserving of inclusion, for the religious type person who feels superior, feels spiritually superior to the tax collector.

It’s maddening to see the tax collector included, which brings us to the last group of people Jesus encounters in our passage. The rabbis, these scribes of the Pharisees, the teachers of the law, or at least their representatives. It’s the religious establishment. Some of them would have been called rabbis, some of them wouldn’t. I only use the term rabbi because it makes for a more catchy message title, right?

Paralytic, tax collector, and the rabbi. Sounds more intriguing than religious establishment. I certainly don’t mean all rabbis were against Jesus. Jesus, they were not. Nicodemus, for example, seems like he followed Jesus privately and then publicly, right?

And so, if you happen to be a rabbi, okay, this is not aimed at you, but the majority of the religious establishment at the time were furious with Jesus. They thought, tax collectors can’t be included.

We are. We are the Jesus should be eating with us.

And Jesus tells them the most terrifying thing God could ever say to any of us. He says, I didn’t come for you. I’m not here for you. You are not part of what I’m doing.

It was the final straw, understandably, for the establishment.

You can just imagine the establishment following Jesus around through this sequence of events, right? First, people with chronic illnesses can have favor with God. That was certainly challenging for them. Second, Jesus shows even the worst type of sinners can find forgiveness and be included, even bigger challenge for them. But at that moment, and before they asked questions or Jesus said anything, at that moment in their minds, they’d have to be assuming, I guess Jesus is just going to include everyone, right?

Is that what’s happening here? Jesus is a universalist. God just accepts all of us. We’re all included. I mean, if paralytics and tax collectors can be included, conclusion, everyone must be included, right?

From their point of view, it had to have looked like that. That. But then Jesus says, no, that’s not what I’m saying. Not everyone is accepted. Not everyone is included.

Namely, you are not accepted.

Final straw for the religious establishment, the establishment who for sure thought they were in, Jesus says, you are out.

The obvious question is, why would the rabbis, so to speak, be out? Not all of them, again, I’m not speaking categorically, but many of them, why would they be out? If the worst sinner could be in, how could anyone be out? Especially pretty good people, you know, people living pretty good lives, like the religious establishment was. How could they be out?

The answer is, as we’ve said, moral goodness is not what gets you in. You need something else. And Jesus hints at it here, but it’s fully explained elsewhere. Jesus says to the establishment, I came for the sick, not the healthy. Implied question, which one are you?

I came for the sinner, not the righteous. Which one are you?

Do you see what Jesus is doing? He’s trapping them. They are forced to choose between 2 options, neither of which they want. They certainly don’t want to call themselves sinners. They don’t want to think of themselves of having anything in common with those sick tax collectors.

Collectors. They don’t want that, but they also don’t want to be excluded.

And Jesus has pitted their pride against their acceptance.

They can’t have both.

So, with Jesus, we see it’s not the good who are in and the bad who are out, but it’s the humble who are in and the prideful who are out. Jesus tells these good religious people. You must identify as a sick sinner like these guys over here that you can’t stand or you’re out.

Religious establishment largely couldn’t do it, probably because they had worked so hard on being good. They thought they had made it. They had climbed morality mountain. And of course, they weren’t spiritually sick like these unsavory tax collectors over And that’s the problem.

All they needed was need, and they didn’t have it.

They couldn’t see themselves as spiritually needy, and that is the indicator of whether or not you are in with God.

Do you know that you have need?

Again, with Jesus, it’s not the good who are in. It’s the humble who are in, those who can admit they have need. The reason why the humble are in and the prideful are out is because if you don’t see yourself as needy, you will never understand the cross. The cross will make zero sense to you if you don’t see yourself as spiritually bankrupt. You’ll look at the severity of the cross and you’ll ask, why would Jesus have to pay for my sins like that?

I mean, sure, I’m not perfect, but I haven’t done anything that would require that drastic of a payment to clear my record before God.

The cross won’t make any sense to you if you don’t see yourself as that needy.

So, you won’t accept it. The religious establishment couldn’t accept it. They could not lump themselves in with spiritually bankrupt, unsavory people. You know, don’t tell me that I have the same need as them. I am better than them.

Meanwhile, many of those those unsavory-type people, not all of them, but many of them had no problem admitting their need, and they rejoiced that Jesus had met it for them. The question, of course, is which group are we? The religious establishment or the unsavory?

That’s hard to admit, isn’t it? We clench our teeth. Humility is hard. Because we think we’re pretty good. I mean, maybe we need a little forgiveness here or there, but I certainly don’t need the crucifixion of the Son of God to cancel the debt I owe.

I don’t owe that much.

It’s so easy to slide in the direction of the religious establishment, so easy to think that we’ve climbed morality mountain It’s so effortless to look down on others who haven’t.

So easy to be judgy.

So easy to be out.

May God forgive us. May He show us how needy we are.

And may we rejoice that Jesus paid what was necessary to restore us through crucifixion.

Let’s pray.

Father, thank you for including even the worst of us, Lord.

Thank you that you will pick any of us up. Thank You the only requirement to get to You is to have need of You.

I pray that we all see our need, Lord, that we will confess it, that we will call ourselves needy, and we will embrace what You provided to restore us. We pray all those things in Jesus’ name. Name. Amen.