What Do You Do When You’re Not Sure?

John 20:24-29

The Bible reminds us that God remains on His throne, even amidst difficult times in the world or trying personal circumstances in our own lives. Despite this, however, the storms of life still have a tendency to challenge our certainty. What should we do in those moments?

Join us this week as we continue our “This is My Story” message series and explore how doubt is not something to hide or fear, how it can actually be the doorway to a deeper, more grounded faith, and how Jesus meets us in our uncertainty with patience and mercy.


Sermon Transcript

Well, we are continuing in our message series that we have been in all summer. If you are visiting with us, and I do see some visitors, you came to celebrate the baptisms that we just had, or maybe you just happened to come here on this Sunday, I am glad that you are here. We are calling this sermon series, This Is My Story. One of the questions we as pastors often get is, why doesn’t God work in the same way today that we read about in Scripture? And the reality is, is He does.

We just sometimes aren’t connecting those dots in those ways. He might not part the Red Sea or bring down manna from heaven, although He could certainly do that, but God uses a variety of means today to speak to us in the same way that God spoke to, say, Abraham or to Rachel or Rebekah or Sarah in Scripture or to Jonah or any of these people that you read about in Scripture. The same God is speaking and working today. So today we’re going to hear from somebody who’s super important to me in my life and to our family, my friend Tom Hanson. If you don’t know Tom, Tom is one of our deacons, and for a period of time he in fact was the chairperson for our deacon body.

But he has a heart for service. I’m so glad you get to hear Tom’s heart. He has meant a lot to me and to my family because he’s taken an interest in my kids. He’s always asking about how the kids are doing. He’s always asking how me and Shannon are doing.

He’s been in my man group where we watch movies together and pretend like we’re intellectuals, and we’ll talk about them afterwards. We’ve shared many a drink at Starbucks together, just commiserating together. Also, fun fact about Tom you need to know, he reads something that you young people may not have ever seen before. It’s called a newspaper. Tom loves a good newspaper, and he, in fact, will sometimes take pictures of an actual newspaper article and say, this is great.

I love that about Tom. We love Julie. We love his kids. I love that God has brought them here. Would you help me to welcome Tom Hanson?

And as before Tom shares, I’d love to pray for him. God, I want to thank you for my brother, and I’ve been lifting him up in prayer as he’s sharing from his heart about a really important topic that all of us, I think, can relate to in one way or another. I pray that you would prepare our hearts, and Lord, you have been preparing him. Speak through him with boldness and with clarity and with joy. We as a church body are of one mind and one heart with him, and we affirm the work that you’re doing in his life, and we celebrate that.

And we pray, God, that you would open up our eyes to see that you speak and work in our lives in similar ways today. Thank you, God. We pray in Jesus’ name. Amen. Thanks.

All right, well, good morning everyone, and thank you, Steve, for that very kind introduction. For those of you who I have not yet had the opportunity to meet, my name is Tom Hansen. My family has been coming to Bridges since the spring of 2019. In true Silicon Valley fashion, my wife found Bridges online after we had done a fair amount of church shopping. I knew we had found the right place when Focus on the Family and Chick-fil-A were mentioned during the first sermon in enthusiastic and positive fashion, as good of a litmus test for the theological position that we were looking for that I’m aware of.

After attending for several months, we joined as members in early March of 2020 on the very last Sunday before the widespread shutdown and commencement of the pandemic era. In 2022, our family was blessed by the birth of our son Christopher, followed by our daughter Haley Ann. On the screen, you can see my wife, Julie, son, Christopher, and baby, Haley, who’s actually here with us today and just celebrated her 2-month birthday last week. Depending on whether you’re talking to me or my wife— hand for baby Haley.

Christopher is in the nursery, but he will someday, I’m sure, watch this. Depending on whether you’re talking to me or my wife, our family may or may not also consist of 2 neighborhood cats. That one of us, and again this depends on who you talk to, has either bribed or befriended with kitty treats in order to encourage their visits. I’m honored and humbled to have the opportunity to speak to you today and take part in our current series, This Is My Story. I’d like to begin with a word of prayer.

Dear Heavenly Father, thank you for this church and thank you for your church. Thank you for this opportunity to speak and please let my words be an accurate reflection of what you would have me share. As David asks in Psalm 19:14, may the words of my mouth and the meditation of my heart be pleasing in your sight, O Lord, my rock and my redeemer. Amen. When I was asked to speak as part of the series, I felt led to cover my personal, previously closely guarded, and to be honest, still ongoing struggles with doubt.

Think about doubt and then match that concept with a biblical figure. If you’re like me, your mind is probably coming up with the Apostle Thomas, or Doubting Thomas, as he is perhaps better known. How appropriate that we share both our names and a similar struggle. So today, after a brief introductory 2-minute video clip, I will share about a Doubting Thomas, the biblical Thomas, and finally, what I’ve learned about how to respond to doubt. A Doubting Thomas, the biblical Thomas, and how to respond to doubt.

What do you do when you’re not sure?

That’s the topic of my sermon today.

Last year, when President Kennedy was assassinated, who among us did not experience the most profound disorientation?

Despair. Which way?

What now?

What do I say to my kids? What do I tell myself?

It was a time of people sitting together, bound together by a common feeling of hopelessness.

But think of that.

Your bond with your fellow being was your despair.

It was a public experience. It was awful, but we were in it together.

How much worse is it then for the lone man, the lone woman, stricken by a private calamity?

No one knows I’m sick.

No one knows I’ve lost my last real friend.

No one knows I’ve done something wrong.

Imagine the isolation.

Now you see the world as through a window. On one side of the glass, happy, untroubled people, and on the other side, I was born into a Christian family and grew up in the church. I accepted Jesus as my Savior at a young age and was baptized in junior high. Some of my earliest memories include attending Sunday school, then the progression through elementary, junior high, and senior high programs at church. I consider this a blessing, having had lifelong benefit of role models.

And godly instruction from my parents, family, friends, and mentors in the church. You may notice, however, I’ve covered a fairly long time period without much comment, and that’s because, to tell you the truth, not much happened as far as significant life-changing events, challenges to faith, or really much difficulty at all. Also a blessing in many ways, but leaving this protective bubble at the beginning of adult life presents some obvious challenges. How do you respond to those with different beliefs, especially if they are challenging your own? How do you defend your faith without having had to previously do so, growing up surrounded by fellow believers but also lacking any crises of faith?

How do you respond to tragedy seemingly without cause or purpose? What do you do with the doubts that inevitably ensue? Now quoting back from the video clip, how much worse is it then for the lone man who stricken by a private calamity. Imagine the isolation. You see the world as through a window.

On one side of the glass, happy, untroubled people. And on the other side, you. I first heard these words in January 2009 while sitting in a darkened movie theater, closely mirroring the dim season of life I was in at the time. Only a few months before, I had graduated with much fanfare from the UC Davis School of Veterinary Medicine, culminating an 8-year journey and fulfilling goals and aspirations dating back to the 8th grade. I then joined a longstanding and renowned veterinary practice near my hometown, where I was certain I would continue to continue my success throughout my entire professional career.

6 months later, I was living at home with my parents, depressed and unemployed, following a short and spectacular decline, then departure from my dream dream position. Then came the onset of a national recession, making the prospect of gainful employment in my field a bleak one. I was dealing with doubts in myself, my abilities, my value, my future prospects, certainly feelings not uncommon to all of us from time to time. But in addition to these, I was fighting a more unique, hidden, progressive, repetitive, and ultimately debilitating blend of fears. Did I lock the door to my house?

Did I remember to turn off the stove? What was that unexpected and unexplained bump in the road? Did I wash my hands enough before cooking dinner? Did I just pour detergent in the wash or did I accidentally use a bottle of Roundup instead? Did I really see the credit card approved flash briefly on the checkout screen or did I just walk out of the grocery store with a cart full full of unpaid groceries.

Reasonable concerns perhaps when limited to a brief consideration. The problem became my seeming inability to erase my consciousness of these fears despite ever-increasing, time-consuming, and elaborate efforts to prove that they were untrue. Before long, I had voluntarily stopped driving in order to avoid the inevitable and literal hours of circling in a vain attempt to confirm that each and every unexpected and unexplained road noise was definitively accounted for as a pothole, leaf, or car rattle, and that every new sound in the succeeding circling was in turn also confirmed to be benign instead of a possible cyclist, dog, or child I feared I hadn’t seen. I repeatedly wore the same clothes over and over, limited survivals from a wardrobe that had been thrown out in the remote possibility of it having received a roundup wash.

I could never leave my home without checking, then rechecking, then checking again, then walking away only to return to check that the door was in fact locked. These problems compounded on each other and were joined with new fears to the point where my world shrunk down to spending most of my time sleeping on a recliner in the family room, utterly exhausted from the incessant fears and and the mental and physical gymnastics I thought that were required in order to ward them off. On January 13th, 2009, I was diagnosed with obsessive-compulsive disorder, or OCD, also known appropriately as the doubting disease. So what is OCD? Common perceptions include the need for absolute cleanliness or the continual readjustment of objects until they are just the right position.

These can indeed be features of OCD, but like many illnesses, it can manifest in different ways and in various severities from person to person. Some of its concepts are easier to explain, such as cleanliness and order. Some are harder to understand, certainly for the unaffected, but even more so for those with this disorder.

At its core, OCD starts with a thought. By thought, I’m referring to consideration we recognize as being part of ourselves, such as What should I make for dinner? Or, why do I think that having a reasonable, balanced discussion with my 3-year-old about bedtime or food choices will ever be successful? This is differentiated from a voice, as in the voice you’re hearing right now from me, or those from a television show that you recognize as clearly being separate from yourself. Thoughts can be voluntarily— voluntary or involuntary, and in OCD tend to come in the form of worries, what-if statements, which again are reasonable at their core.

Most, if not all of us, locked our car in the parking lot. Most, if not all of us, washed our hands before preparing food, with good reason. The problem becomes with the inability to have peace of mind with the overwhelming likelihood that that fear has a remote, if any, possibility of happening. This isn’t a problem with perception, cognition, or spirituality. I can no longer delete this fear or this thought from my mind than somebody with diabetes can will their pancreas into making more insulin, or a nearsighted person can correct their own vision.

Inevitably, feelings of anxiety lead to a need to reduce or escape from that anxiety, and that’s where the compulsions, or the C part of OCD, come in. These can be seen externally as obsessive washing, ordering, or checking, or internally with the repeated recollection of memories in an attempt to gain certainty about a particular situation. In his excellent memoir on his experience with OCD, Rewind, Replay, Repeat, former KCBS radio news anchor Jeff Bell describes verifying his parking brake is set in the following way. Quote, I have all 5 of my senses but tend not to trust any of them. Take touch and sight in their most basic functions.

At my worst, I can be seen holding a parking brake with my hand, seeing it fully secure and feeling it locked and immovable. Yet the moment I let go or look away, I lose all comprehension of its fixed condition. I can rattle, re-rattle, and re-re-rattle the handle, double back to my car a dozen times, and still there is no convincing myself, no means of storing in my sensory input or watering off laser doubt-driven urges to replay the whole sequence in my head again and again. And so it is with far too many day-to-day challenges. End quote.

Compulsions sometimes bring relief, at least for a while. The problem is when they do not, and OCD is infinite in its creative ways of disrupting and casting doubt on attempts to attain certainty. More often, the compulsions reinforce the obsessions, which lead to more compulsions, and around the circle we go. During my journey with OCD, I have been thankful first for a Heavenly Father who will never leave nor forsake me, Deuteronomy 31:8, and also for the most effective triad of therapy for OCD from which I continue to benefit: the support of family and friends, counseling, and medication. Through this, I have learned that both doubt and recovery from OCD are spoken to with faith, and I mean that not in a trite or simplistic way.

Let me, let me explain. In Matthew 14, we learn about Jesus feeding the crowd of 5,000 starting with 5 loaves and 2 fish, with 12 basketfuls of leftovers being collected after the meal. He sent the disciples ahead of him in a boat to the other side of the lake where he went up a mountain to pray. A storm arose while the boat was far from land. Quoting from Matthew 14, verse 25, during the 4th watch of the night, Jesus Jesus went out to them, walking on the lake.

When the disciples saw him walking on the lake, they were terrified. It’s a ghost, they said, and cried out in fear. But Jesus immediately said to them, take courage, it is I. Don’t be afraid. Lord, if it’s you, Peter replied, tell me to come out to you on the water.

Come, he said. Then Peter got down out of the boat, walked on the water, and came towards Jesus. But when he saw the wind, he was afraid and, beginning to sink, cried out, Lord, save me! Immediately Jesus reached out his hand and caught him. You of little faith, he said.

Why did you doubt? What’s the lesson here? Peter has faith, at least enough to step out of the boat onto stormy water and walk, which would otherwise be impossible. And initially, he was successful. Very quickly, however, as is often the case with plaguing doubt and anxiety, he let his focus shift from the true solution and security back to his fears and circumstances, and he started to sink.

The most commonly prescribed therapy for OCD, known as ERP, or exposure with response prevention, works in much of the same way. Under the direction of a licensed OCD therapist, ERP consists of staged, controlled, and deliberate exposure to fears, limiting and preventing the drive towards compulsive responses. It’s a little bit like putting your toe in a cold pool. If you periodically dip your toe in, decide it’s too cold, and pull it out, you will never acclimate to the pool. It’s only through deliberately leaving your foot in the pool that you’re able to adjust to the temperature.

I need to continually remind myself that God is always with me in my doubts. I can call on him and he will listen. He has said to cast our anxiety on him because he cares for us. Doubt is indeed a burden and it causes weakness, but I can come to him where I will find rest. This is the anchor I need to remember when doubts are swirling in order to have confidence in therapy, where the only way out of doubt is through it.

The intent of our current series, My Story, is to show that the one and same God behind creation, who parted the sea for the Israelites, sent his Son to live among us, turned a few loaves of bread and fish into meals for thousands, and blamelessly died and rose for our sins is the same God that we know today. Far from an abstract, distant, or unapproachable concept, he is working now, just as in biblical times, and we can draw inspiration from the people he has used. Let’s have a look at the most famous doubter. In John’s account, Jesus has been crucified, resurrected, and already appeared to Mary Magdalene. He subsequently appeared to disciples, showing them his hands and side, John 20:20.

Thomas was not with him at the time, and then when those disciples told him later, quote, he said to them, unless I see the nail marks in his hands and put my finger where the nails were and put my hand into his side, I will not believe. I will not believe it. John 20:25. A week later, Jesus appeared to the disciples again, this time including Thomas. Then he said to Thomas, put your finger here, see my hands.

Reach out your hand and put it into my side. Stop doubting and believe. Thomas said to him, my Lord and my God. Then Jesus told him, because you have seen me, you have believed. Blessed are those who have not seen and have yet believed.

John 20:27-29. Thomas is the same guy who earlier in the book of John responds to Jesus’ description of his Father’s house having many rooms and that he is going there to prepare a place for them with the following: Lord, we don’t know where you are going, so how can we know the way? John 14:5. What are some observations that we can make about the biblical Thomas? Clearly, He’s someone who struggles with uncertainty.

It’s easy for me to look back and say, Doubting Thomas, you have literally had a front row seat to Jesus’ ministry. You have witnessed evidence supporting what he has said with your own eyes multiple times. Yet you seem to have this repeated issue with uncertainty and need for reassurance. It’s easy for me to forget the other things that I have looked to for certainty. Being in with the right crowd, Wearing the right things, having a certain job, looking a certain way, being younger, being older, driving a certain car, titles, where you went to school, did you go to school, popularity, image, climbing the ladder.

How does Jesus respond to Thomas? Quote, I am the way and the truth and the life. Nobody comes to the Father except through me. If you really knew me, you would know my Father as well. From now on, you do know him and have seen him.

John 14:6-7. Jesus didn’t get angry. He didn’t kick Thomas out of the group. He didn’t shame him. A gentle reproof, yes, similar to his response to Peter on the lake.

In these and other cases, he allows questions. And he responds to them with proof, as with his wounds following the resurrection. Thomas was an imperfect person who made mistakes and who sometimes struggled with doubt. The Bible is full of such examples with these kind of track records and yet God still uses them for his purposes. And that’s good news for us today.

Finally, I want to share with you what I’ve learned about how to respond to doubt. And I want to be clear, I am still learning and relearning and then needing to remind myself of these, of these phrases. I’m still very much in the midst of my doubt journey and will be for the rest of my life. I need to hear these things regularly just as much as anyone else. First, a reminder of our worth as children of our Heavenly Father from a favorite song of my son’s that he’s been asking me to play lately at bedtime.

From Megan Wood’s song, The Truth. The truth is I am my Father’s child. I make him proud and I make him smile. I was made in the image of a perfect King. He looks at me and wouldn’t change a thing.

The truth is I am truly loved by a God who’s good when I am not good enough. I don’t belong to the lies. I belong to him. And that’s the truth. What’s the message?

We have inherent value, not because of who we are or what we have or haven’t done, but because of whose we are. This remains true despite tremendous societal pressures that make us feel otherwise. As C.S. Lewis writes in Mere Christianity, nearly all that we call human history— money, poverty, ambition, war, prostitution, classes, empires, and slavery; the long, terrible story of man trying to find something other than God which will make him happy. The relational opportunity with him is always there; we just have to accept it.

So how do we hear God and be in a relationship with him? Pastor Steve gave the following advice for how to hear God during the recent sermon series, Finding Your Way. Number 1, ask him to speak to you. Steve recounted the story from 1 Samuel of how one night Samuel was sleeping, only to repeatedly awake at the sound of his name.

Each time he went to Eli the priest thinking he was the one who had called him. As, quote, Samuel did not yet know the Lord, the word of the Lord had not yet been revealed to him, 1 Samuel 3:7. Each time Eli said, no, I did not call you, and sent him back to sleep. Finally, Eli recognized it was the Lord that was calling Samuel and advised him to, quote, go and lie down, and if he calls you, say, speak, Lord, for your servant is listening. 1 Samuel 3:9.

If we call to him, he will answer. Jeremiah 33:3. Let his word be a lamp unto your feet and a light for your path. Psalm 119:105. Speaking to him can sometimes feel like a challenge, especially during times of profound grief, anxiety, or other difficulty.

Prayer doesn’t have to be complicated, eloquent, or lengthy, however. Anybody who’s familiar with Pastor Chuck Swindoll’s tremendous teaching and writings on scripture might be surprised to hear that he has referenced times where he sat at his desk and all he could muster as a prayer was help. Another great preacher, Charles Spurgeon, was quoted as saying he rarely prayed, prayed for more than 5 minutes long, but he never went 5 minutes without praying. God knows us, he knows our hearts, and he knows our needs. When we don’t know what to pray for, the Spirit himself intercedes for us with groans that words cannot express.

Romans 8:26. Number 2, listen to what he says. He may respond in a variety of ways: through another person, circumstances, or directly. He may respond through what he has already said, his word. He may respond immediately, eventually, or in a different way than we may expect.

I have also heard this said that the answer may be yes, no, wait, or he has something different planned for us. Finally, number 3, do what he tells you to do. This may be costly, inconvenient, or uncomfortable, but we have been entrusted and commanded to share God’s word and and the hope that he provides with others.

You are the light of the world. A city on a hill cannot be hidden. Neither do people light a lamp and put it under a bowl. Instead, they put it on its stand, and it gives light to everyone in the house. In the same way, let your light shine before men, that they may see your good deeds and praise your Father in heaven.

Matthew 5:14-16. And therefore, go and make disciples of all nations, Baptizing them in the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit, and teaching them to obey everything I have commanded you. And surely I am with you always, to the very end of the age. Matthew 28:19-20. We are truly living in times of urgent physical and spiritual need.

It seems that hardly a day goes by without a new calamity. While preparing for this talk, I was keeping out for such events as likely to raise doubts, or at least questions, among Christians and non-Christians alike. Unfortunately, recent weeks have provided more than enough material. In Idaho, a man started a wildfire and then started shooting at the firefighters who responded, killing 2. A fully loaded plane crashes into a dorm for a medical school in India shortly after takeoff, killing 260 people, including 19 on the ground.

And of course, the recent and still unfolding unimaginable tragedy at Camp Mystic. Borrowing some words from the clip at the beginning in response to these events, who among us has not experienced the most profound disorientation, despair? Which way? What now? What do I say to my kids?

What do I tell myself? It is a time of people sitting together, bound together by a common feeling of hopelessness. You could see why people would doubt. Is there a God at all? If there is a God, isn’t he supposed to be good?

If there is a God and he’s supposed to be good, where is he in this? How could a God that exists and is good allow such things to happen? How much worse is it then for those that do not have the hope that we have, that this is our temporary home, and in this world we will have trouble, but take heart because he has overcome the world, John 16:33, and will take what was meant for evil and redeem it, even if it’s beyond our perception or lifetime. This is not in any way to negate the profound sadness in the wake of tragedy. The Lord is close to the brokenhearted and saves those who are crushed in spirit, Psalm 34:18.

It also does not excuse common trite responses from otherwise well-meaning people, which too often are cold comfort at best and insulting at worst to those in the midst of the storm. It does, however, speak to the need for us to create relationships with each other and every other person, especially those who do not yet know that they also were fearfully and wonderfully made in the image of God and share in an equal amount of his love. It underscores the need to mourn with those who mourn, Romans 12:15, and speak into doubt the reasons for the hope that we have. Even if we can’t explain it, and even if we don’t have answers, we can point to the one who someday will wipe every tear from their eyes. There will be no more death or mourning or crying or pain, for the old order of things has passed away, Revelation 21:4.

In a world of doubt, he is our certainty. As you go out in the world and face your own doubts, remember Romans 15:13. May the God of hope fill you with joy and peace as you trust in him, so that you may overflow with hope by the power of the Holy Spirit. Let us pray.

Dear Heavenly Father, thank you for the gift of salvation through the death and resurrection of your Son, Jesus. A free gift available to us through faith and not the results of our own efforts. Please grant us the humility to know that we can do all things through you who give us strength and to share this hope with those who do not know you, always with gentleness and respect. Guide us towards open doors of conversation in all things, serving as ambassadors and reflections of your love. In Jesus’ name, amen.